Tuesday, December 7, 2010

Police and Masterton Court conspire to pervert the course of justice again.

Judge Broadmore has decided to hear the matter of Alan Donoghue telling lies today, and I have been remanded until 2:15. Half the Masterton Police were lounging around the courtroom as usual, with nothing better to do, muttering and mumbling, while cellphones went off and louts (friends of the complainant, Donoghue, from what I could see) sniggered and carried on like the imbeciles they are, the Masterton Court's like a circus most days.

I told the Judge I had been given illegible copies of documentary 'evidence', and a typed transcript which is alleged to be of the audio recording on a small dictaphone tape I was also given at the last hearing. On average, one in three of the lines on the transcript is of me saying "I want a telephone to speak to a lawyer without delay please (well all right then, maybe not please every time)", and one in three is "INAUDIBLE", according to the Police typist.

The tape was apparently a result of Constable Mia Wilton's habit of wearing a recording device, with which she records people without their knowledge routinely.

The charge has been laid under Section 9 of the Summary Offences Act

Police know perfectly well that I have never assaulted Alan Donoghue - Donoghue assaulted me. Police know perfectly well that Donoghue's 'evidence' just does not stack up, and they have refused to take my complaint about him assaulting me. They are well known for their creativity when fabricating evidence against me and in excusing the actions of serious violent offenders like Donoghe, who told me he spent years in prison for armed bank robbery among other things. The Disclosure Act says somewhere that any previous convictions of the complainant are to be disclosed. Section 12 and 13 of the Criminal Disclosure Act says:

Section 12: Initial disclosure
  • (1) At the commencement of criminal proceedings, or as soon as practicable after that time, and in any event not later than the applicable date, the prosecutor must disclose the following information to the defendant:
    • (a) a summary that is sufficient to fairly inform the defendant of the facts on which it is alleged that an offence has been committed and the facts alleged against the defendant; and
    • (b) a summary of the defendant's right to apply for further information under subsection (2) before entering a plea; and
    • (c) the maximum penalty, and the minimum penalty (if one is provided for), for the offence; and
    • (d) a list of the defendant's previous convictions that are known to the prosecutor; and
    • (e) a list of any previous offences proved to have been committed by the defendant and of a kind to which section 284(1)(g) of the Children, Young Persons, and Their Families Act 1989 applies, that are known to the prosecutor.
    (2) At any time after criminal proceedings are commenced or, in the case of a child or young person who appears in a Youth Court in relation to the commission or possible commission of an offence, at any time after that person's first appearance in the Youth Court, the prosecutor must, if requested by the defendant in writing, as soon as is reasonably practicable disclose the following information to the defendant:
    • (a) the names of any witnesses whom the prosecutor intends to call at the hearing or trial; and
    • (b) a list of the exhibits that are proposed to be produced on behalf of the prosecution at the hearing or trial; and
    • (c) a copy of all records of interviews with the defendant; and
    • (d) a copy of all records of interviews of prosecution witnesses by a law enforcement officer that contain relevant information; and
    • (e) a copy of job sheets and other notes of evidence completed or taken by a law enforcement officer that contain relevant information; and
    • (f) a copy of any records of evidence produced by a testing device that contain relevant information; and
    • (g) a copy of any diagrams and photographs made or taken by a law enforcement officer that contain relevant information and are intended to be introduced as evidence as part of the case for the prosecution; and
    • (h) a video copy of any video interview with the defendant; and
    • (j) a copy of any statement made by, or record of an interview with, a co-defendant in any case where the defendants are to be proceeded against together for the same offence; and
    • (k) a list of any information described in paragraphs (a) to (j) that the prosecutor refuses under section 15, 16, 17, or 18 to disclose to the defendant, together with—
      • (i) the reason for the refusal; and
      • (ii) if the defendant so requests, the grounds in support of that reason, unless the giving of those grounds would itself prejudice the interests protected by section 16, 17, or 18 and (in the case of the interests protected by section 18) there is no overriding public interest.
    (3) This section does not apply to a defendant who is charged with a minor offence as defined in section 20A(12) of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957 or with an infringement offence as defined insection 2(1) of that Act.
    (4) In this section, applicable date means—
    • (a) the date that is 21 days after the commencement of criminal proceedings:
    • (b) in the case of a child or young person who is required to appear in a Youth Court in relation to the commission or possible commission of an offence, the date on which that person first appears in that Court:
    • (c) any later date that the Court or Registrar allows, on application by the prosecutor, for the purposes of disclosure under this section.

Section 13: Full disclosure
  • (1) The prosecutor must disclose to the defendant the information described in subsection (2) as soon as is reasonably practicable after a defendant has—
    • (a) pleaded not guilty to an offence proceeded against summarily; or
    • (b) elected trial by jury under section 66 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957; or
    • (c) if the information has been laid indictably, made his or her first appearance in Court in relation to the offence.
    (2) The information referred to in subsection (1) is—
    • (a) any relevant information, including, without limitation, the information (standard information) described in subsection (3); and
    • (b) a list of any relevant information that the prosecutor refuses under section 15, 16, 17, or 18 to disclose to the defendant together with—
      • (i) the reason for the refusal; and
      • (ii) if the defendant so requests, the grounds in support of that reason, unless the giving of those grounds would itself prejudice the interests protected by section 16, 17, or 18 and (in the case of the interests protected by section 18) there is no overriding public interest.
    (3) The standard information referred to in subsection (2)(a) is—
    • (a) a copy of any statement made by a prosecution witness; and
    • (b) a copy of any brief of evidence that has been prepared in relation to a prosecution witness; and
    • (c) the name and, if disclosure is authorised under section 17, the address of any person interviewed by the prosecutor who gave relevant information and whom the prosecutor does not intend to call as a witness; and—
      • (i) any written account of the interview, whether signed or unsigned, and any other record of the interview; and
      • (ii) any statement made to the prosecutor by the person; and
    • (d) any convictions of a prosecution witness that are known to the prosecutor and that may affect the credibility of that witness; and
    • (e) a list of all exhibits that the prosecutor proposes to have introduced as evidence as part of the case for the prosecution; and
    • (f) a list of all relevant exhibits in the possession of the prosecutor that the prosecutor does not propose to have introduced as evidence; and
    • (g) a copy of any information supplied to the prosecutor in connection with the case by any person or persons whom the prosecutor proposes to call to give evidence as an expert witness or witnesses; and
    • (h) a copy of any relevant information supplied to the prosecutor by a person or persons whom the prosecutor considered calling to give evidence as an expert witness or witnesses, but elected not to do so.
    (4) The obligation to disclose information to the defendant under this section as soon as is reasonably practicable is subject to any order made under section 30 or 32.
    (5) If information referred to in subsection (2) comes into the possession or control of the prosecutor, or is prepared in recorded form, after the prosecutor has disclosed information in accordance with subsection (1) and before the hearing or trial is completed, the prosecutor must disclose the information to the defendant as soon as is reasonably practicable.
    (6) The entitlement of a defendant to information under this section continues while the criminal proceedings are in progress (including any appeal against conviction) and during the period from the conviction until the expiry of the time for lodging an appeal against conviction.
    (7) To avoid doubt, a reference in subsection (1) to pleading not guilty includes—
    • (a) denying the charge under, or in accordance with, section 20A(5) of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957; or
    • (b) requesting a hearing in accordance with section 21(6) of that Act (unless the request is accompanied by an admission of liability); or
  • (c) denying the charge during any appearance before the Youth Court under Part 4 of the Children, Young Persons, and Their Families Act 1989.
    __________________________________________________________________

And this is Section (8):

Meaning of relevant
  • In this Act, relevant, in relation to information or an exhibit, means information or an exhibit, as the case may be, that tends to support or rebut, or has a material bearing on, the case against the defendant.

    Donoghue's statements are a pack of lies and so is the evidence of the Police. His criminal record is very relevant. What this matter comes down to is an issue of credibility, Donoghue's word against mine. But there is another element to it, the credibility of the Police involved in 'investigating' Donoghue's complaint.

    The Police leapt into action recently, jumped into their cars and attacked me without delay after Tim Reynolds rang up and said "Kate's taken my bike" - he hung up, then the call taker records how she took some trying to ring him back to confirm whether or not he wanted to make a complaint about it, and how he answered the phone and hung up on her three times. No complaint was ever made, but after I was attacked by corrupt Constables Pope and Dallinger, and after they kicked in the bedroom door of a 14 year old girl to drag me out in handcuffs, bashing my head on the door frame for good measure, Reynolds still hasn't made a complaint, but I was long ago convicted of the great crime of swearing at the police, on the basis of nothing but the word of the two constables. The witty judgement of Sir Owen Woodhouse in the Napier Supreme Court (yep) of the Kinney Appeal springs immediately to mind: if a lady swears (and frankly, anyone would have, under the circumstances), and nobody is offended, is it a crime? Police note the name of a lady who I will not name here, who was allegedly within hearing distance, but Police couldn't get her to make a statement of complaint obviously. They are just counting on the fact that appealing is not easy if you don't have a lawyer and I am very busy trying to get my head around all the different corruptly laid charges, like the matter of Michael Murphy and Aaron Brook, Wayne Friend, etc. Those names will mean something to regular readers of this site, and as soon as I get more time I can link up the kaleidoscopic manner of organising (ha ha) the information on the site, shifting it to other sites and generally organising the information in a format in line with the aim of Transparency in New Zealand, to tell the story of corruption throughout NZ and to link the allegations to the Evidence - and that's a really key part of it, the linking of the information. I'm getting there, with little more than the clothes on my back and a bicycle, I am still giving them a run for their money because it's better to die on your feet than to live on your knees, and I am sick of being accused of things I didn't do.

    Also, Police conducted door to door enquiries to see if they could find anyone at all who might have been offended, but of course they couldn't - just like they couldn't find a single member of the general public to give evidence at the meeting to discuss the Carterton Community Centre/ Facility/Event Centre debacle. They stormed into the meeting like the Gestapo in front of horrified witnesses - 150 or so of them, and dragged me out in handcuffs in spite of everyone telling them to arrest Georgina Beyer, and witnesses were so horrified that they wrote to the Prime Minister, the Area Commander of the Police, etc - and these were people who didn't even know me, never mind my friends, and they were prepared to come to Court and give evidence too and had made sworn statements accordingly, they were credible professional people, a psychologist, a schoolteacher, good decent people, not like Donoghue and his loutish, scruffy, unemployed mates.

    So when I received a letter from the justice department saying they were going to take even more money out of my pathetic $249 a week for bike helmet tickets and allegedly swearing at the Police (that's the other thing, they put my address down as all sorts of things, in this case it's another address where I was not even living) anyway I was very upset about this because I had filled in several Form 57 Court documents about the fact that my mail has gone to all sorts of addresses because Police have recorded all sorts of wrong addresses, including addresses, recently, where I don't even know the occupants. My address has remained the same since I moved from 13 Brooklyn Road, nearly 2 years ago, but Police like to send my mail all over the place and harass all sorts of people by turning up at all hours, parking outside for hours, kicking in little girls' doors, etc.

    Julian Assange has been remanded in custody today pending the hearing of an application to extradite him to Sweden. I don't in any way compare myself to Julian Assange, despite announcing that this site shall henceforth be known as Kiwikileaks or Kiwileaks or whatever it is, but I firmly believe the strategy is the same. Police Sergeant Kevin Basher is quoted in an email from Police as having an unhealthy interest in my website, here's what it says, and note that Police have refused to provide the full message to date, it was requested on the 9th September:

    "Kevin Basher- To Sergeant Murray Johnston--07/09/2010 07:47:45---Something needs to be looked at regarding RAUE using her 'Blog" to make statements regarding our sta"

    Other evidence they have refused to provide is the CCTV footage of the brutal attacks on me by Constables Dallinger, Wilton, Peters, etc, or the CCTV footage of me happily co-operating with the strip search involving just me and that nice Constable Dana Johanson, or her evidence that I was totally co-operative with her thorough search, unlike other officers who who lied, alleging I was "unco-operative, abusive" etc.

    The charge being heard this afternoon carries a six month prison sentence. I don't remember being asked if I wanted a jury trial and I'm pretty sure I should have had the choice.

    There is considerable evidence on this site of letters of apology to me from the Police which refer to " differences of expectation between Prosecutions staff and other police" and "Procedural disputes within the Masterton Police at present" and considerable evidence of fabricated evidence and corrupt and incompetent practices and policies within the Wairarapa Police. There are a relatively considerable amount of evidence of the validity in the form of letters from lawyers, such as the ones from Ken Daniels, Michael Appleby, Frank Minehan, Nikki Pender, etc,

South End School - corruption turns into perjury:

This is the document written by corrupt Police Constable Harvey Pope and presented in Court as the basis for charges against me.  It is blatantly untrue and corrupt.  It is a serious attempt to pervert the course of justice and slander and defame me further.

There was no "bad behaviour" whatsoever on my part, if there had been, there would be a record of it, a note, an incident report, there is no such thing.  If there had been, it would have been mentioned in the letter to me from the Board (below).

"Efforts to sever ties with Raue turned hostile."  Yes, they did.  I received the letter dated 25 March 2009, after Police called a meeting with School staff and the Board of Trustees, and at this meeting Police slandered and defamed me, and lied in saying that they had charged me regarding the allegations of Michael Francis Murphy and Tracy Feast.  Efforts to sever ties with me coincided with funding grants to the school for the vegetable garden, which I had created at some personal expense.  The Board, who had shown no interest in the Garden for a year and a half, suddenly wanted to take it over and get rid of me when it was established and producing good crops, after I'd done all the work with no help from them whatsoever.

I told the school principal and deputy principal repeatedly that the accusation in the letter was untrue and I had never been charged with any such thing in my life.  I also repeatedly asked for a meeting with the Board of Trustees to discuss the matter, and all these requests were refused.  Board member Emily Brown turned up  unannounced at a friend's home while I was visiting and began raving on in front of my friend about how she was concerned about my mental health and had contacted police and mental health.  There's clearly something wrong with Emily Brown's mental health, my requests for a meeting were appropriate, polite, and entirely logical.  The Board of the South End School is corrupt and needs to be replaced.

Of more concern is that Constable Pope and other Wairarapa police are corrupt liars, who have instigated a number of malicious, vexatious, corrupt prosecutions against me.  Also of concern is the policy of local police of sharing all information about individuals with "community organisations", which is described in a front page newspaper article, published in October 2008 in the Dominion Post.  This post is about how that policy actually works, the evidence speaks for itself.

Police shared information about me with Michael Murphy, who then came to my home and violently attacked me.  I raised concerns about Michael Murphy neglecting his child and his violent behaviour, police told him I'd raised concerns, which is the only thing they did about the allegations at all, and encouraged Murphy to come and attack me.  They also encouraged him to return to my home some weeks later to steal a computer disk I had acquired with evidence of his violent attack on it.  Murphy has never been charged for the attack, nor have his co-offenders.

Repeated requests for "all information about me held by the school" have been ignored, the school lied to the Privacy Commissioner, and denied having received any letters of complaint from parents regarding the letter sent to me and the actions of the Board and staff, until confronted with the evidence.

Pope charged me with Offensive Language.  The statements of his witnesses refer to me calling the Principal and Groundsman "liars", "thieves" and "corrupt" - not offensive language at all, statements of true fact, unlike the documents presented to the Court by Pope.  Pope has long history of corruption during his career, which is why he's never been promoted.  Pope told the school he'd charged me with an offence, which was nothing more than wishful thinking on his part.


I have now been ACQUITTED of this charge after the complainants failed to turn up to Court - aware that they would be immediately charged with perjury if they attempted to repeat the orchestrated litany of lies which I now have EVIDENCE of - INDISPUTABLE EVIDENCE THAT THE CLAIMS AGAINST ME ARE NOTHING BUT AN ORCHESTRATED LITANY OF DELIBERATE POLITICALLY MOTIVATED LIES!  An update on these matters can be found at this link.

Sunday, December 5, 2010

Police Complaints Authority responses corrupt:






Above are responses to the submission to the Police Complaints Authority from Michael Appleby, following the public meeting in Carterton to discuss whether to give 6 million dollars to the same people who took over out last community centre and closed it down amid allegations of fraud and serious misfeasance, and let them just build another one and run it as corruptly as the last one.

Below is another letter from Mr Appleby.  The matters refered to in paragraphs numbered 3-5 inclusive have never even been acknowledged or addressed in any way, this is evidenced by the responses:
_____________________________________________________________________________
Wellington
Phone: (04) 9349 389
Mobile: (0274) 40 33 63
Email: m.g.appleby@gmail.com
Police Complaints Authority
Level 5
342 Lambton Quay
P O Box 525
Wellington

16 February 2008

Your Honour,
Re: Kate Raue – your ref 05-0761/ghe:bpd
Thank you for your letter of 1 February 2008, enclosing the documents sought.
The letter of complaint dated 8 June 2007 contained a further paragraph 5 that appears to have been inadvertently deleted from the actual letter which you received.
I attach a copy of the letter as it should have been, and you will note that Mrs Raue wished a further separate investigation into the reluctance of the Masterton Police to actually investigate the frauds and illegal takeover of the Carterton Community Centre, frauds which her previous lawyer, Mr Ken Daniels, himself believed to have been committed.
This protest at the refusal by the Masterton Police to investigate these matters was explicit in the paragraph 5 that was inadvertently omitted from the letter actually sent to you.
In spite of the implicit complaint against Police Officer Murray Johnston in paragraph 4, the response ignores this.
A copy of the response from the Masterton Police to me dated 22 November 2007 was sent to me at the address of the Police Complaints Authority, PO Box 5025 Wellington, and it was finally resent to me on 10 December 2007, but not received by me until 5th February.
It seems from that response by Inspector Johnston that he has not addressed the refusal to investigate the fraud by Sgt Murray Johnston.  Are the two men related?
The protest in the complaint at the refusal by the Police to investigate these allegations was certainly made explicit in the missing paragraph 5, but it is clear from paragraph 4 that this refusal by Sgt Murray Johnston should have been investigated by Inspector Johnston.  It was not.
His response dated 22 November 2007 makes no reference to it at all, and in view of the inability of the Authority to complete its investigation for several more weeks (as advised to me by your office on 5 February 2008), there appears to be time for the Authority to ask the Masterton Police as to why they treated the original complaint into fraud in such a cavalier way, when Mr Daniels had clearly indicated that he himself had serious concerns.
A further example of their cavalier attitude is contained in their letter of 28 July 2003, attached “A”, to Mrs Raue, as if the Mayor and MP, Georgina Beyer, were sacrosanct, and immune from investigation.
Please investigate Officer Murray Johnston’s behaviour, as well as the other breaches of Mrs Raue’s human rights as set out in the actual letter sent to you by me on the 8th June 2007.
I look forward to your advice as to this further explicit complaint, as well as the other complaints regarding the breaches of Mrs Raue’s rights.
Moreover the response dated 22 November 2007 by Inspector Johnston, at page 3, comments that it is standard policy and practice at the Masterton police station not to have accepted Mrs Raue’s handbag from her friend Mr Allomes even though her medicine was in it, yet another admission by the Police that their particular branch appears to ignore the fundamental right set out more particularly by me in the “Twenty Third Breach” that “everyone deprived of liberty shall be treated with humanity and with respect for the inherent dignity of the person.”
The Police could have quite easily searched the handbag, and confiscated any items that they thought were inappropriate, before giving the handbag containing her personal items and medicine to Mrs Raue.
Moreover, Inspector Johnston’s comment in his penultimate paragraph, that “from the Doctors observations of her, he was able to give an opinion, which was that she did not require medication at the time” is simply quite untrue.
A copy of the relevant Trial transcript containing the Doctor’s evidence is attached “B” from which it can be seen that the Police Doctor, Dr McGrath actually stated under oath that he did not even recall seeing Mrs Raue at the police station, at all, and that he had no record of seeing her.
Although Inspector Johnston has conceded in his response that a number of Mrs Raue’s rights were breached, I believe it was appropriate, really, that he address each and every breach of Mrs Raue’s rights as set out in my letter: i.e: all twenty seven breaches individually, rather than the selective approach he has taken, merely responding to four of the criticisms by Judge Behrens, or the five matters he chooses to deal with as set out on page 2 of his letter.
It would have been of more assistance, surely, if Inspector Johnston had dealt on a thorough and professional basis with the twenty seven breaches complained of.
It should also be noted that Inspector Johnston was actually rung up personally the day after the political meeting by Mr Kennedy, a concerned citizen who was aghast at the treatment meted out to Mrs Raue.
Inspector Johnston however refused to either interfere in the prosecution of Mrs Raue, or to order his officers to at least question, and take statements from, other more neutral witnesses.
Inspector Johnston’s own behaviour in this sorry saga seems to not be beyond reproach, and it appears inappropriate that he has conducted the investigation.  A neutral Investigator would be more appropriate to investigate the background of the behaviour of the local police, rather than the local Inspector, who seems part of the problem.
I would be grateful if you would advise the Authority’s next step, and the time frame within which you expect the complaint to be finalised.

Yours sincerely,

Michael Appleby
_________________________________________________________

Michael Appleby  B.A.  LL.B.  LL.M. (Hons), Barrister of the High Court of New Zealand
15 Fairview Crescent
Kelburn
Wellington
Phone: (04) 9349 389
Mobile: (0274) 40 33 63
Email: m.g.appleby@gmail.com
Hon Judge Goddard
Police Complaints Authority
Level 5 
342 Lambton Quay
P O Box 525 
Wellington

30 May 2007

Your Honour,

  1. Further to Judge Borrin’s letter of 9 December 2005 (a copy of which is attached for your convenience and ease of reference), I write to confirm that all of the five charges have been thrown out by the District Court, and partial costs awarded against the New Zealand Police.
  2. I attach some relevant documents in connection with Mrs Raue’s complaint.
  3. Further background to the history of the treatment of Mrs Raue by the Masterton Police is the letter of 26 August 2004 from Mrs Raue’s previous counsel, Mr Ken Daniels, to the Police calling their attention to what Mr Daniels himself believed to be fraud at the Carterton Community Centre.
  4. The only response to this letter seems to have been the brief e-mail dated 26 April 2006, from Police officer Murray Johnston, admitting that he couldn’t remember Mr Daniels letter, that he couldn’t locate the file, and scoffing at any allegations which might have been made in the letter from Mr Daniels, even though he couldn’t even remember receiving the letter.  The e-mail states:  “Any such allegation by Kate against the Community Centre management would take a very low priority from a Police perspective.  Her allegations about the Community Centre have mostly proved unfounded, emotive and simply not credible”, even though Mr Daniels is a Lawyer, and had expressed his concern at what he himself believed to be fraud.
  5. The Masterton Police have, apparently, made no further investigations into Mr Daniels’ concerns about the fraud, nor do they intend to do so from the tenor of the email.  This obviously requires further investigation by the Authority and constitutes a separate complaint.


Yours faithfully,

Michael Appleby




This has been going on since the Carterton Community Centre was illegally taken over in 2001 by seriously assaulting the Secretary and Treasurer in the office of the Centre, and stealing all the assets of the Society to conceal the fraud.

You can see that the first letter at the top of the page was addressed to my lawyer at the address of the Police Complaints Authority - which meant that it was not received by us for months!  Very unprofessional!  These letters show that the fraud and misfeasance at the Carterton Community Centre, committed by the very same people behind the planned Event Centre - which all well informed members of the community oppose for very good reason, have been deliberately and corruptly ignored by local police and the PCA.









 

The letter above is once again a predictable litany of excuses, more information will be put up here in the following weeks, so keep an eye on this post which will be regularly updated with more copies of this correspondence.  The third page of this letter is particularly damning, it actually admits that Senior Constable Jackson refused to look for the medical reports I had provided immediately to the police after the assault on me, because he "couldn't be bothered getting off his backside"!!!!!  But the PCA thought this was alright!