Thursday, June 10, 2010

Rachel Betteridge commits perjury, conspires with police to bring deliberately corrupt malicious prosecution

Here's the story of lying local prostitute Rachel Betteridge of Masterton, who made false complaints to the police, that I had sent her "over sixty offensive text messages".

I never sent Rachel Betteridge any offensive messages - Rachel Betteridge is a liar.  She and her husband sent me several seriously offensive and threatening messages, saying things like "You need a bullet", "watch your back", false accusations that I sexually abused my own daughter, and other filth.

Below is Betteridge's Brief of Evidence, used in the prosecution of me over her false and malicious allegations, in which she dishonestly claims "I did not reply to any of the messages", and the signed statements of two Justices of the Peace, and Betteridge's own father, in evidence that she did, and that she did therefore commit perjury, deliberately.

Corrupt local Police lied in Court, and committed perjury, when the prosecutor claimed to have tried to obtain information from Vodafone about the messages, and the several long phone calls to me from Betteridge around the same time.  Vodafone confirmed in writing that the police never even contacted them about the matter, never even requested any information.  Police wasted time and tax payer's money pursuing a corrupt prosecution.  There was never ever any evidence of Betteridge's lies, it does not exist, the claims are lies, like the lies in the letter from the South End School.  Lies spread by the police, Gary McPhee, and disgraced ex MP Georgina Beyer the Liar.  I never rang Betteridge or sent her any offensive messages, the police know perfectly well I didn't, and pursued the corrupt prosecution deliberately, despite knowing it was corrupt and an abuse of power, abuse of the Court process, and a blatant attempt to pervert the course of justice!  - Which is why I was acquitted!

Two Justices of the Peace would have convicted Betteridge, if they had been sitting in the Masterton Court, all the evidence proves that Betteridge is a nasty malicious, lying prostitute (she worked at Mermaid Bar in Wellington, and is now a "self employed" prostitute,) if the police had bothered to charge her when I showed them this evidence.

Betteridge showed the police NO evidence whatsoever in support of her lies against me - because none whatsoever ever existed, because Betteridge is a liar who made it up and the police know that, which is why they refused to contact Vodafone and request the evidence!

The transcript of the evidence, and the judgements will be up soon, watch this space for more evidence of police corruption and conspiracy between Court Registry officer Liz Harpleton and corrupt police prosecutor Gary Wilson and his mates to pervert the course of justice in the Masterton Court.

Here's Betteridge's Brief of Evidence, here's a handwritten statement from her father, Colin Allomes, and the statements from the Justices of the Peace:








I filed a private prosecution against Betteridge in the Masterton Court.  Corrupt lawyer Jock Blathwayt of Wollerman Cooke and McClure conspired with Court staff to have it struck out in the face of this EVIDENCE, "for want of prosecution".  Click on this link to see how blatantly obstructive and corrupt Court staff commonly deal with applications from people like me, Vince Siemer, and others who seek justice in the New Zealand Courts.

And as for Betteridge's lies about how her father had apologised to her - read her father's statement to the Court for yourself!

Corruption in the Masterton Court: Mrs Deputy Registrar & Mr Police Prosecutor cheat on their spouses, shack up together, then judge the rest of us:

The Masterton Court deputy registrar Liz Harpleton and Masterton police prosecutor Garry Wilson both cheated on their spouses and shacked up together a while ago, and they now conspire to pervert the course of justice in the Masterton District Court as often as possible.

This is a letter from a nasty, corrupt little man called Bryan Yeoman.  He's an ex police officer who perfed out of the police force when he found an easier and much more lucrative way to get his snout in the trough by being an amicus curiae, or "Friend of the Court", a very airy fairy, nebulous but very highly paid position.  He specialises in 'representing' vulnerable mental health patients, achieving predetermined outcomes in exchange for bribes.  I wrote to him and asked him when I had to be in Court in January 2010, he told me not till February 23rd.  I received an urgent message to tell me that a warrant had been issued on the 16th - it was no coincidence that the warrant was issued the very day after I'd had a conversation with the husband of a woman called Jenny.  Jenny's been having it off with the same local police officer as Jo Roffe (Constable Stephen Wakefield - it's well known in Carterton that Wakefield is a sleazy disgusting creep who abuses his powers to get sex, and like he let Roffe and her mates off with the illegal takeover mismanagement and closure of the Carterton Community Centre, he let Jenny's neice, who we'll call Tracy, off will stealing $500 from a local woman who shall remain nameless (because it is not in the community's interests that she needs to be named, he also made sure that Michael Francis Murphy got away with a home invasion at my home and Gary McPhee got away with another such attack, and Jenny's son Hayden got away with smashing my window and threatening and terrorising me and witnesses who were present in another violent incident), after Tracy told the victim of her theft that she needed to borrow the victim's car and drive to my home urgently, because she (Tracy, the thief) had received a phone call from me and Jenny's son, who we'll call Hayden, asking her to come to my address because we had rung her and said  we'd heard an intruder or some such thing.  Hayden, and I and the victim of the theft went to the Carterton police station and tried to make statements to Constable Harvey Pope that Hayden  and I had been at my house at the time Tracy alleged to the victim, and the police, that we had rung her, and that neither he or I had phoned Tracy, proving indisputably that she was lying to the police and the victim.  Pope refused to take statements from Hayden and I regarding the alleged phone call, and apparently left all reference to it out of the statement he took from the victim.

Wakefield wrote, and also got his fellow officers to write, letters of support for Jo Roffe's funding applications for her "crafty youth" programs, run through the former Carterton Community Centre as part of the rip offs that saw her pocketing over $600 for running a shambolic and useless craft program for "troubled youth" - young criminals, etc.  The community gardens did way more to help these people into employment, drug programs, parenting programs, etc, than Roffe's silly course ever did!  You can learn most of what she was teaching at any local kindergarten, and Roffe is on a par with disgraced ex politicians Georgina Beyer and that drunken lout Gary McPhee as far as community role models go!

Other attempts were made to pervert the course of justice involving Jenny and her mates, including after the attack on  me on 11th February 2009 at 13 Brooklyn Road, when Jenny came to the house unannounced the day after the attack and drew over a crack made by the attackers in the door with a felt pen, and made repeated visits over the next few days making other attempts to conceal and repair the damage to the door, despite repeated requests from me that she not do so until the police had photographed the damage. Photos were eventually taken by Constable Cadwallader, but these have never been provided despite numerous requests.  Independent witnesses took photos however, and described how the attackers were smashing the door down at the time the attack was taking place.  The police refuse to acknowledge that the attack even took place in spite of calls to 111 from four witnesses while the attack was taking place, describing it in graphic terms.  There was another incident involving Jenny's son - Constable David Gallagher's brother in law - making serious threats on a number of occasions, trespassing, and one occasion smashing a window and threatening me and another woman who was present and two young children, while Constable Pope and Constable Cunningham watched and did nothing (see witness statement below).

Meanwhile the Carterton District Council were taking me to Court alleging that I trespassed after being forbidden to enter the Council chambers by Gary McPhee.  I instructed my lawyer to advise the Court that McPhee was never legally elected and therefore could not trespass anyone from the Council chambers.  The Judge agreed, I was acquitted.  McPhee was furious.


 
This is about how Liz Harpleton and Gary Wilson, Court Registrar and Police prosecutor conspired to pervert the course of justice in the Masterton Court, and imprisoned me on an illegally and corruptly obtained warrant issued on 16th February 2010 to punish me for the conversation with Jenny's husband, during which he confirmed that he knew that the attackers did the damage to the door on the 11th February and that he knew his wife lied to the Tenancy Tribunal in April (or May) and told them that I did the damage, and sought money for the damage from me, knowing that I hadn't done it.  He confirmed that he had known for years that his wife has been having it off with Constable Wakefield and that is (just one of) the reasons his family receives favourable treatment from the police.  Jenny's daughter is married to another police officer, and her son has never had a job in his life, receives a benefit from the tax payer, but owns several houses and cars, and came to my home in April and threatened a woman and two children who were visiting, and myself, and smashed a window, in another terrifying attack, while Jenny and her husband and the police, stood and watched and did nothing whatsoever, despite the police having served him with a trespass notice weeks earlier because of his daily visits and threatening behaviour.  These conflicts are rife in the Wairarapa, the husband of Court registry officer Liz Harpleton walked in and found her and police prosecutor Garry Wilson at it on the floor, both were married with kids, neither one of them has any moral compass and both are as corrupt and depraved as you could imagine.  It's an extremely serious and totally unacceptable conflict of interest and blatant corruption for them to be cooking up corruption together in the Masterton Court and everyone knows it!

We'll start with this record of the discussion between Ken Daniels and I (and a witness), which is accurate to a degree, but omits a large amount of the lengthy discussion indeed. This refers to a meeting regarding the charges of trespass at a Council meeting which were later thrown out because the Judge agreed that McPhee had no lawful authority to evict me, as I told the police in the first place.

One of the points I wanted made very clear to the Court was that I had not disrupted the meeting whatsoever, I had spoken briefly on a few matters including:
1    I requested the return of my electoral nomination deposits.
2    I requested the return of property belonging to Friends of the Carterton Community Gardens, which was taken unlawfully and unreasonably by the Carterton District Council and gifted to one of their employees, Melvin Pike, and other people.
3.   I presented a petition calling for an inquiry into the affairs of the Carterton Community Centre, and the involvement of several individuals associated with Council in the illegal takeover, mismanagement and closure of the CCC, particularly the accounts "compiled" by Council accountant/employee Lyn Patterson, and the manipulation to appoint Patterson by Brazendale, Carter, Greathead and the other individuals referred to, and related matters referred to in the volume of complaints from me, the petition, the letters from numerous lawyers, scathing comments from several judges, witnesses such as the complaint made after the public meeting about Ewen Hyde and Bill Knowles, exclusion of certain members of the public from Counci deliberations but not others, undeclared conflicts of interest, etc, all of which has been put in writing and not responded to.
4.   I complained that I had been denied my lawful rights to be heard in support of my submission, by Ewen Hyde, who had written different letter to different submitters depending on whether he wanted them to be heard or not and who had deliberately  provided false information to Council in order to exert undue influence of the grants of funding he had applied for.  I said that all well informed people in Carterton want an inquiry into the former Carterton Community Centre, and do not support the planned "Event Centre" replacement CCC.

McPhee then told me to shut up and get out.  I reminded the Council that I had just sat and listened to disgraced ex politician Georgina Beyer go on about her new "job" as the Wairarapa anti violence co-ordinator, and Teri Lenihan go on about the Wairarapa Safer Community Council, both women spoke for considerably longer than the time afforded to me (twenty minutes in each case for them, less than five in my case).  I said I understood that speaking rights were for five minutes and I had not been granted that because McPhee was afraid of the truth.

McPhee got up and approached me with his fists clenched, then when I said "Look at him - take a look at yourself - the only way you can ever sort out anything is with your fists" he seemed to wake up to the fact that the whole Council and about a dozen members of the public were watching him, so he walked to the door and opened it and demanded I get out.

I said, no, I am entitled to stay and listen to the meeting, unless the public are excluded, and I should be treated no differently to anyone else, and excluding me for no reason in fundamentally undemocratic, and  discriminatory, and against the New Zealand Bill of Rights.

I then sat down quietly with the other members of the public.

McPhee then stood there like an idiot, shouting and carrying on like the attention seeking drama queen of a big girls blouse that he is, which was rather amusing for a while, and when that didn't work he ran next door to the police station and wasted police time again, making a complaint when there hadn't even been a crime committed.

I also told Ken that I had requested the Minutes of the Council meeting from the CEO and the Mayor, as soon as the charge was laid, and these had also not been provided.

So, less than a week later, there we all were in Court - me, McPhee, Ken Daniels, and Bryan Yeoman, the ex police officer amicus curiae who has somehow managed to get his snout in the trough and has been stuffing things up as hard as he can ever since he was appointed.  Below is the record of the "rather strange events of 9th June 2009", and an urgent letter to the police, after Judge Tuohy refused to disqualify himself, requesting the documents that McPhee was reading from when the trial was stopped:








Here's the statement from the witness to the offence, and the police refusal to arrest the offender they allowed to smash a window and terrorise me and another woman and two little children:










Wednesday, June 9, 2010

Kirsten Grenfell of Barnardos:




Wayne Friend, Kirsten Grenfell, Rachel Taylor




9th August 2010.

Court tomorrow (more corruptly laid charges), it's about 2 degrees outside at the moment, a howling southerly and sleet.  I have nowhere to live and cannot access my belongings, including warm clothes, documents I need for Court, etc, because of this so called "charity worker", Kirsten Grenfell, who 'works' for Barnardos.

Kirsten Grenfell rang up my friend and the owner of the property where I live (Tim Reynolds) the other night, told him a pack of lies and threats, including that she was going to send her mates, the cops and the president of the Upper Hutt Mongrel Mob, round to "deal to me", and ordered that he evict me.  Then she asked to speak to me, the cheeky, troublemaking tart.  I said I didn't want to speak to her.

This matter began when Kirsten decided to send an email gossiping about me through Barnardos email system, under the heading "This is a Taita community initiative", and she has been causing trouble and domestic violence in the Wairarapa ever since she started having an affair with my partner, and it's time we looked at how our donations to charity and taxes are really spent, and what the cause of the social problems in the Wairarapa really are.  It's not what you know, it's who you know.  Grenfell's been earmarked as a political stooge, like her boss, Murray Edridge, Paula Bennet's lackey for the Green Paper on vulnerable children - Grenfell and Edridge EXPLOIT vulnerable children for their own profit - nothing is more obscene!

Kirsten Grenfell arranged for her mate Wayne Friend to shift in and threaten and assault me every time I go home.  He and his mother are best mates with Michael Murphy, who attacked me at Brooklyn Road on 11th February 2009 and is conspiring to pervert the course of justice.  Not content with evicting me into the freezing cold and taking possession of my property and making sure I can't access any of it, she incited him to report his bicycle stolen - we lived miles from anywhere, Reynolds told me to leave, my bicycle had a puncture, Reynolds routinely allowed me to borrow his, he had about a dozen cars registered and warranted and has never ridden his bicycle once anyway, and after he asked me to leave I just wanted to comply with his request.  He mentioned it as an afterthought, and confirmed that I complied with his instruction to leave promptly, and that he didn't want to make a formal complaint regarding the matter.

On the basis of that feeble call to 111 - for which both Reynolds AND the call taker should be charged forthwith with Wasting Police Time - Police kicked in the bedroom door of a 14 year old girl to assault me in front of her, handcuff me, bash my head into a door frame, lock me up in handcuffs in a cell for a few hours - for nothing - for riding down the pavement on a Sunday afternoon, minding my own business.  I wasn't charged with stealing the bicycle - because it WASN'T stolen - and there has been NO formal complaint that it has!  All because of Kirsten Grenfell of Barnardos and her little games.

Constables Dallinger and Pope charged me with swearing at the police after they bullied and harassed me instead of getting on with what they're paid to do.  Wairarapa police are wasting taxpayers money persecuting decent, innocent people and this is quite possible why Wairarapa has such high rates of crime and suicide, because the police waste their time bullying me instead of solving the hundreds of uninvestigated child abuse cases.

I am homeless, freezing, often hungry, and disgusted that so-called charity workers, like overpaid troublemaker Kirsten Grenfell have got their snouts in the trough of donations to charity and taxpayer funding to spend their time sending gossip about me through Barnardos email with the intention of causing a great deal of domestic disharmony and violence.  Intentionally and deliberately.  As Kirsten put information on the internet about me, I'm going to put it on there about her, because I have been contacted by several other women who have suffered domestic violence because of her nasty troublemaking by chance, and suspect there are others.  Kirsten used to work in a chemist shop before being sought out by Barnardos or so she tells everyone, I think she's better suited to that than anything involving families.  Too many people like her get their snouts in the trough through charity organisations.

The Carterton Community Centre was wound up because the people who took it over by punching the Secretary/Treasurer in the face and changing the locks to cover up the fraud going on there involving Carterton District Councillors, told the High Court that the reason for winding it up was that "due to a change in the way the government is delivering social services there is no longer a need for a community centre in Carterton."  What rubbish!

Changes in government policy have delivered power to people like Kirsten Grenfell and her managers - people like Murray Edridge, Paula Bennet's "Green Paper" Puppet (who condones her actions in a short email saying "Kirsten denies your allegations" - which is why I'm putting her email, etc for all to see - which part of this does she deny?) and local bully Tere Torea (more about him soon).  The same people involved in the fraud at the Community Centre have just gone on to waste money and rip off other organisations and their clients, it's absolutely rife in the Wairarapa - the Secretary and Treasurer of the local A&P society just defrauded them of about $50,000 because he was involved in not one but three internet scams.  And this is after I've been going on about the fraud at the Community Centre for ten years - they still think I'm the criminal element in Carterton and Gary McPhee and Georgina Beyer are fine upstanding role models in the community.  Kirsten Grenfell likes people to think butter wouldn't melt in her mouth and she's a caring community minded person.

Kirsten works for Barnardos, she had a little fling with my friend for a few months last year, to indulge her little fireman fantasy.

She got bored and dumped him, sending him texts saying:

1.  Hi Xxx the flowers were nice thought and offer of tea, thank you.  I need to finish  things between us, please just respect my wishes.  I hope you will chase your dreams but    


2.  please don’t text me etc., sorry it hurts I know.  Thanks for everything, and your kindness to ruby.  Take care of yourself, Goodbye, Kirsten


3.  Thanks for being big about this, I know that hard and takes a lot to do - I thank you.  Please don’t try to hold on or give me space and try again, it won’t work.  May luv, light and peace be yours x

After she dumped him to go back to her old boyfriend Dave, who it sounds suspiciously like she was cheating on in the first place, I moved in, and my friend and I enjoyed a happy life together until my friend's phone went on the blink and he asked me if he could put his sim card into my phone to check his messages.  It seems the messages were held in the memory of my phone after he removed his sim card, because I found the messages above, and a more recent one saying:

"Got a punch in the gob from Dave's ex, but the cops are going to deal to her ha ha"

Then checking our emails found this:

From: Kirsten Grenfell
Date: Wed, Aug 19, 2009 at 1:06 PM
Subject: The Tim report
To: Mr X


Hey Xxxxx


Hows it going mate!  Ran into Tim the other day at the mall, had a chat and a cuppa as you do….


Anyway your name came up and I gave him the hard word about getting an email address and keeping in touch etc.  and he actually has one!


He did ask me though what happened to all the emails that got sent - did they go to everyone's computer?! (yeah, I said, you just have to scroll down and find the ones from your mates) classic…. I told him it was all good, only you would get it :-)  But I wouldn’t hold your breath!


So, as he doesn’t have a PC at home and the whole deal is a bit daunting for him, he wants me to wish you a


Happy Birthday for the 26th!!!


and to tell you that he's going to Aussie soon for Guy's 50th and that you should meet him there!  sorry I don’t know many details…


Otherwise he is all good, Kate has moved in apparently, Tim is saving hard and likes the extra dosh he is getting from his job now that he moves around the different stations.

Hope you are well and happy Xxxxx and I wish you a wonderful day on the 26th too!  Go hard!


Ok, tarrah, I will text Tim and tell him to get his butt down to an internet site sometime to see if he has mail from you.


Take care,


Kirsten

A Taita community initiative
held by Barnardos NZ


Kirsten Grenfell
Ph: 04 567 KIDS (567 5437)


This e-mail message has been scanned for Viruses and Content and cleared by MailMarshal
image001.png
17K   View   Download  

A Taita Community initiative indeed!  We had a pc, had the internet, and were in regular contact with our friend ourselves, my flatmate told me he didn't tell her we didn't have a pc at home at home at all!  Every woman I've spoken to thinks it's out of order to dump someone like that and say don't text me etc, then take over "the Tim report" to all his mates, saying "Kate's moved in apparently," etc.  If you dump someone and another woman moves in, keep out and mind your own business and don't email their mates with the news about them.  Furthermore, she hardly knew our friend.

The thing is, she knew I went round there every night for dinner before she began her little fling, and had been more than just a friend.  I was good about it when she came along, I didn't go over for dinner every night, but picked them up from the pub and drove them home sober after they'd been drinking and anything else I could do for my friend and her.  She was polite but not friendly toward me, and made the odd comment such as "I have to remember not to speak Maori in front of you people" - you people?  I asked why she had to try and not speak Maori in front of "us people", having established that she meant us in the Wairarapa as opposed to her other friends.  She said "Because you wouldn't understand."  What a cheeky, arrogant, ignorant tart!

She works for Barnardos, a so called Christian organisation which offer domestic violence courses, she rang up here the other night and threatened to send her mates in the Mongrel mob round to deal to me.  The so called "news" report at this link is an example of her half witted idea and her self promotion, this pathetic "initiative" is typical of her "community works" - people want to be empowered themselves, not rely on her, this idea is ridiculous and a complete waste of time and money.  Many so called 'charity workers' are paid far too much money for providing 'services' that are of questionable value to their 'clients' compared with other viable alternatives that actually meet the real needs of their 'clients'.  Media journalists promote their favorite 'charity workers' and their initiatives, we've got a few of them over here.  What is this videophone worth and  how accessible is it really?  My hearing is impaired so I send faxes - we don't need this 'initiative' - it's a waste of money!  Apparently we're paying for the interpreter as well as Kirsten Grenfell to make all this happen, because although Kirsten tells us she's fluent in te reo, she doesn't do sign language.

Barnardos will send her on lots of courses to learn it though.  She spends her time filling in funding applications for things like this, going on team building exercises, etc, and talking about the things she's going to do if she gets the funding.  This is how your donations to Barnardos are spent - enriching Kirsten Grenfells life.  Round here we just do it whether we get the funding or not, Grenfell won't do it unless she gets paid handsomely for her "efforts".

After she'd dumped him, and after she'd sent the emails, she came over one night and slept with him again, then started texting him every night which led to a negative change in his behaviour toward me.  I glanced at his phone on the table one night when it lit up with the message saying "Dave's working tonight, doing security at Johnsonville, want to come over?"  Another said "Just got a smack in the gob from Dave's ex".  - No wonder she got a "smack in the gob" - she richly deserves it!

I emailed her and told her what I thought of her for sending my friend an email about me headed up "This is a Taita Community Initiative for Barnardos", discussing my private and personal living arrangements and appointing herself in charge of "The Tim report" and making up excuses to contact our friends - and so would most of the women I know - what a cheek!.  She denied sending it - the LIAR!  - The EVIDENCE of it is there in black and white!

She knew I'd moved in, she'd sent him emails saying "Don't text me" etc, and she should have minded her own business.  My flatmate complained that she wouldn't introduce him to any of her friends during the time they went out, but she wanted to take over the Tim Report after she knew I'd moved in, through the Barnardos email, with "this is a Taita Community initiative all over it!"

She hadn't felt comfortable sneaking over to sleep with my friend while her partner was working while I was there, and convinced him that if he got rid of me she's resume the affair.  He got ever so excited at the thought.  She also said she was going to get her mates in the Mongrel Mob to come and "deal to me".

Because of these threats about the Mongrel Mob, he immediately went out and bought some big locks and chains and put them on the gate evicted me, and abused me for upsetting her.  Kirsten Grenfell is just a dishonest trouble maker and a slapper of the lowest order, who associates with methamphetamine dealers and thieves.  If CYFS saw where she takes her daughter they would remove the child from Grenfell's "care" on the spot.
Karen Friend

Dallas Powell
This is Wayne Friend's mother Karen Friend who plays a key role in the matter of the South End School.  She's best mates with Michael Murphy.  She's also a local drug dealer, like her son, who is a methamphetamine addict. 

She's also best mates with the corrupt local police and local drunken bully, corruptly elected Mayor, Gary McPhee.  She often runs the bar at the Seven Day Club, McPhee's popularity has waned somewhat, even there I'm told.  Ex Deputy Principal of the South End School Dallas Powell has also been pressuring and blackmailing my friend to get rid of me because she comes out there to smoke dope where her own neighbours won't smell it and her son won't see, and because she feels I put her in a difficult position regarding the allegation of child abuse from the South End School, this is how the Wairarapa works.

Michael Murphy sent me text messages about five days before he came to my home and attacked me saying "I'm at your house with the cops and Gary McPhee" and "You smell like Satan", etc.

This is Dallas Powell, who was Deputy Principal of the South End School when I got the letter sacking me over the false allegation that I'd been recently (let alone ever) charged by the police with an offence involving a child.

Dallas knows that Rod O'Leary, the Principal is lying regarding his account of events surrounding my sacking, and the letter sent to me by the Board of Trustees of the South End School, but she refuses to simply write and say so.    Dallas is good friends with psychopath Julian Tyerman.

As a result of the letter from the school she was the DP of, and her refusal to admit the facts, I have had no job for over a year.

The we've got Emily Brown, who's on the Board of Trustees of the School, and who lives two houses from me.  When I asked her if she could please facilitate a meeting between me and the Board because the ongoing situation was causing me extreme hardship and depression, she came to another friends' house where I was visiting at the time, and announced to everyone that she was so concerned about my depression that she had rung the police and mental health services!  I asked for a meeting with the Board because they sacked me over a false allegation of child abuse - I am not a criminal or a mental patient OR a child abuser!  I'd like a meeting with the Board of Trustees please.  This is further evidence of Emily Brown's delusions, and her outrageous and nasty behaviour - the fact that she's on a Board of Trustees at all is a matter of serious concern.  Emily's mother and brother committed suicide - like Julian Tyerman's brother - and yet these monsters think it's amusing to incite other people to commit suicide - makes you wonder why their own family members made that decision really, it seems pretty obvious to many people who know them.  Nasty manipulative and dishonest people like this are the reason the Wairarapa regularly has twice the average national suicide statistics - in a country which regularly has among the highest rates in the world, the fact that people like this are in charge of running local schools and "charities' explains at lot, sadly.

Kelvyn Alp has pressured the Ombudsmen into reopening their inquiry into the matter.  That and the disgraceful ERO reports for 2010 and 2011 are evidence that the school governance is still seriously dysfunctional. 

Kirsten Grenfell rang Tim Reynolds because I complained about her gossiping on the internet about me and causing trouble, the complaint was well justified.  Murray Edridge and Niamh Lawless, the CEO's of Barnardos, defend Grenfell to the hilt, denying that she sent the email repeatedly until they were confronted with it, then saying they can't see anything wrong with it.  Then they told Grenfell I'd complained, so she rang and incited Reynolds to throw all my Court paperwork out in the rain, local police refuse to assist me to recover the rest of my property from the address, local police and so called community services aren't doing what they're paid to do they are acting with prejudice and bias, and perverting the course of justice, and supporting the criminals.

Kirsten Grenfell and Murray Edridge of Barnardos are Paula Bennett's stooges, and the sooner we get their snouts out of the trough the better.

"Kirsten denies your allegations" indeed!  The email is INDISPUTABLE PROOF of my allegations!  And I challenge anyone to obtain the further evidence from the email forensic records.  Then there's the matter of "Dave's ex" giving her a "smack in the gob" - there's a pattern there.

Murray Edridge and Kirsten Grenfell are typical of the manipulative liars who slither ever higher up the tree of public funding, Edridge is in charge of  Paula Bennett's "Green Paper" gravy train, a huge waste of time and money - here's the problem, this is what needs fixing.- we don't need a "Green Paper" we need constructive and decisive action regarding these matters - police deliberately throwing hundreds of child abuse files in the bin and deliberately lying about it - nothing whatsoever has been done about the problems in the Wairarapa police - and things are the same around the country - the so called 'inquiry' never even interviewed the ringleaders, McHattie and Johnston, both were actually promoted - instead of imprisoned for this blatant corruption!  

Monday, June 7, 2010

Huge backlog of child abuse cases not investigated

It's been revealed by a District Court Judge that there is a huge backlog of child abuse allegations which have not been investigated by the police (Wairarapa Times-Age August 13 - 21 2009). This internet site site was set up to show people what the police have been doing instead, and how they 'investigate' the allegations that they do receive.

Details of the Wairarapa's disgraceful record of child abuse can also be found on the internet, through the website of the Masterton Library, Searches, Newspaper Index. Type "child abuse" in the search box, sort set by date of publication latest to earliest, and check out the results.

Winter's a good time to search this index, type "suicide" in the box, "murder", "crime", "police", "Gary McPhee", "Georgina Beyer" - but remember - these articles are mainly biased in favour of the police, Beyer, McPhee, etc, according to the editorial bias of the Wairarapa Times-Age toward corrupt redneck bullies.  There are plenty of things you won't read about in the Times-Age:

Today the latest charges against me in the Masterton Court were dismissed, because AGAIN the police had no evidence to offer the Court, AGAIN they just wasted everybody's time.  I said ages ago on this site that the Principal of the South End School Rod O'Leary wouldn't turn up because he has been proven to have lied to the Privacy Commissioner and other people, including the police, and wouldn't dare turn up and swear on the bible because I would have him for perjury in a flash, as he well knows.

Corrupt police prosecutor Gary Wilson wasted everybody's time - and tax payers money - again - when is he going to resign?  When are we going to elect an MP that's going to do something about the corrupt Wairarapa police.  Listen to them bleat about not having enough resources to investigte all the child abuse allegations, and here's Gary Wilson and his girlfriend Liz Harpleton, corrupt Court Registry Officer perverting the course of justice again with this rubbish!  Read the full story of the liars and thieves that run the South End School.  There's more at this link and this one and others.  And after biking a few kilometres to the train station in the rain and hail, and all the way back from Masterton in the rain and hail - for NOTHING - I got home to find someone had let one of the Community Garden horses out of it's paddock.  Great place the Wairarapa.  Let's get rid of the corrupt police and other idiots like McPhee, Beyer, John Haze, etc.

Michael Appleby, B.A. LL.B. LL.M. (Hons) to Police Complaints Authority 30 May: 2007

Michael Appleby B.A. LL.B. LL.M. (Hons)
Barrister of the High Court of New Zealand

15 Fairview Crescent
Kelburn
Wellington
Phone: (04) 9349 389
Mobile: (0274) 40 33 63
Email: m.g.appleby@gmail.com

Hon Judge Goddard
Police Complaints Authority
Level 5
342 Lambton Quay
P O Box 525
Wellington

30 May 2007


Your Honour,

1. Further to Judge Borrin’s letter of 9 December 2005 (a copy of which is attached for your convenience and ease of reference), I write to confirm that all of the five charges have been thrown out by the District Court, and partial costs awarded against the New Zealand Police.
2. I attach some relevant documents in connection with Mrs Raue’s complaint.
3. Further background to the history of the treatment of Mrs Raue by the Masterton Police is the letter of 26August 2004 from Mrs Raue’s previous counsel, Mr Ken Daniels, to the Police calling their attention to what Mr Daniels himself believed to be fraud at the Carterton Community Centre.
4. The only response to this letter seems to have been the brief e-mail dated 26 April 2006, from Police officer Murray Johnston, admitting that he couldn’t remember Mr Daniels letter, that he couldn’t locate the file, and scoffing at any allegations which might have been made in the letter from Mr Daniels, even though he couldn’t even remember receiving the letter. The e-mail states: “Any such allegation by Kate against the Community Centre management would take a very low priority from a Police perspective. Her allegations about the Community Centre have mostly proved unfounded, emotive and simply not credible”, even though Mr Daniels is a Lawyer, and had expressed his concern at what he himself believed to be fraud.
5. The Masterton Police have, apparently, made no further investigations into Mr Daniels’ concerns about the fraud, nor do they intend to do so from the tenor of the email. This obviously requires further investigation by the Authority and constitutes a separate complaint.

Yours faithfully,

Michael Appleby
____________________________________


To The Police Complaints Authority
Wellington


Re: KATHERINE RAUE, D.O.B: 28.7.1958

Complaint regarding numerous breaches of civil rights by the Masterton Police.

1. I have been asked by my above client to refer to you the manner in which she has been treated by the Masterton Police over the last year.

2. The Complainant is a political activist opposed to the building of a proposed $4,000,000 Community Facility in Carterton, where she lives, and attended a public meeting called for the purpose of discussing the merits or otherwise of building the facility. At the meeting she was seized by the Police, who later claimed to have arrested her, although contrary evidence was given by the Police regarding this alleged ‘arrest’. She was later charged with five offences: Trespass, Disorderly Behaviour, Resisting Arrest, Assault and Assaulting a Police Officer.

3. Mrs Raue’s previous Counsel, Ken Daniels, to whom legal aid had been granted, had withdrawn as her lawyer on Wednesday 14 June 2006, and he sought an adjournment accordingly.

4. In despair, Mrs Raue rang Mr Rodney Hide, Leader of the Act Party, to seek his advice and assistance. Mr Hide indicated that he was concerned that the case appeared to involve serious constitutional issues, and civil rights issues, and affirmed the importance of safeguarding free speech in a democratic society. Mr Hide apparently suggested to Mrs Raue that she approach myself for assistance because I was involved in the area of constitutional law and human rights law.

5. I have acted for Mrs Raue since being telephoned by her urgently on the evening of Wednesday 14 June 2006. She asked me to act for her, as she was defending five charges on the following Tuesday 20 June 2006. Two days had been set aside for the hearing, although Mrs Raue’s previous Counsel, Ken Daniels, had apparently originally asked for three days. A copy of his letter dated 1 6 February 2006 in which he expresses concern that the Masterton Police were proceeding with the charges is attached, marked “A”.

FIRST BREACH

6. The Masterton Police opposed that application, in spite of the human rights protected by the NZ Bill of Rights Act 1990, Section 24(d) of which states that “everyone who is charged with an offence shall have the right to adequate time and facilities to prepare a defence.” The Police opposed Mr Daniels’ application, and the District Court refused to grant an adjournment on the Wednesday, based on that opposition.

SECOND BREACH

7. On Thursday morning, 15 June 2006, I traveled to Carterton to gather information and advise Mrs Raue, and at 5 p.m. on that day I filed another application to have the matter adjourned, as I did not have adequate time to prepare a 2-3 day defended Hearing in the few days (including a weekend) prior to the commencement of the trial on the following Tuesday.
8. Again, the Masterton Police opposed this application for an adjournment, and again breached Mrs Raue’s right under Section 24(d) of the NZ Bill of Rights for her (and her lawyer) to “have the right to adequate time and facilities to prepare a defence.”
9. On Friday 16 June 2006 the District Court again refused this application for an adjournment, based on the opposition of the Masterton Police.

THIRD BREACH

10. As a result of the refusal to grant the adjournment on the Friday, I asked several legal aid lawyers to act for Mrs Raue, as I do not do legal aid work.
11. These lawyers advised that they would be unable to act for Mrs Raue on the Tuesday, as they would not have sufficient time to prepare a defence to the five charges she faced.
12. As a result of this, and under great pressure from an ethical point of view, in that I was required under the Law Practitioners Code of Duties and Responsibilities to act for Mrs Raue, as otherwise she would have no legal representation, as is her right under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act, I very reluctantly agreed to act for her, based on my normal legal costs of $200 per hour, knowing full well that she was impecunious and on a benefit.
13. Mrs Raue has, therefore, been faced with a legal bill of $15,639 (see Bill of Costs attached as “B”) as a result of the opposition of the Police, thereby breaching her right under Section 24(f) of the NZ Bill of Rights Act , which states that she “shall have the right to receive legal assistance without cost if the interests of justice so require and the person does not have sufficient means to provide for that assistance.”
14. The District Court Judge, Behrens J., Q.C. dismissed the five charges at the close of the case for the Prosecution, following submissions from myself (and having six witnesses ready to refute the complainant’s ‘evidence’), with the Prosecution agreeing at the end of Counsel’s submissions that the evidence for the Prosecution was, indeed, “tenuous”.
15. The District Court took the most unusual step of granting costs against the Police following Submissions by myself as to the question of costs. Behrens J. granted costs of $3781 instead of Mrs Raue’s actual costs of $15,639, leaving a shortfall of $11,858 to be paid by Mrs Raue as a result of the actions of the Police in opposing the application for an adjournment, and based on their knowledge that they had only “tenuous” evidence against Mrs Raue.
16. An appeal against the refusal to grant actual costs on a lawyer-client basis was lodged with the High Court but this was unsuccessful.
17. Mrs Raue seeks not just damages for the various breaches of the NZ Bill of Rights Act, but also the shortfall between her actual legal expenses of $15,639, and the costs awarded to her of $3781, namely $11,858.
18. A copy is attached of the Judgment by Behrens J. dismissing the three charges of Trespass, Disorderly Behaviour and Resisting Arrest at the close of the second day of the trial on the Wednesday. Judge Behrens adjourned the two further charges of assault, and assaulting Police, until a subsequent date, and on that date he dismissed these two further charges, again at the close of the case for the Prosecution, following submissions from myself, without the Defence needing to call any evidence.
19. A copy of his further judgment is attached, and it can be seen that he took a very dim view of the whole sorry saga.
20. Apart from the three breaches of her human rights outlined above, a perusal of the various attached documents will reveal to you that a number of Mrs Raue’s other human rights have also been breached, namely:

FOURTH BREACH

21. Section 9 of the NZ Bill of Rights Act provides that “Everyone has the right not to be subjected to …… degrading or disproportionately severe treatment or punishment.” The so called “arrest” of Mrs Raue at a political meeting, and her being dragged away by the Masterton Police without their discussing the situation with a number of protesting citizens who were concerned that Mrs Raue had been singled out without any appropriate investigation (apparently for criticising local politicians, and in spite of the efforts of those citizens keen to discuss the matter with the Police), and bustled away like a common criminal, clearly breaches the Right to be not subjected to ‘degrading’ treatment.

FIFTH BREACH

22. And a further instance of degrading treatment and punishment occurred later on at the Police Station when the Police strip-searched Mrs Raue quite unnecessarily, and three of them wrestled her to the floor in an attempt to remove her pounamu necklace, while another approached her with a pair of scissors, threatening her with the possible loss of one of her eyes.

SIXTH BREACH

23. The Police refused to allow Mrs Raue’s friend to pass on her handbag containing her personal items including her heart medication, compounding the degrading treatment and punishment to which they subjected her.

SEVENTH BREACH

24. Moreover, the singling out of Mrs Raue, among an estimated hundred participants in a spirited discussion at a public political meeting was a clear breach of the prohibition under Section 9 of the NZ Bill of Rights Act to not subject citizens to “disproportionately severe treatment.”
25. To treat her like this at a public political meeting was totally out of proportion to the desirability and reality of brisk political debate, at a public meeting which was advertised as being for just that purpose, and, what is more, being the only member of the public to be arrested, compounding the seriousness of this particular breach.

EIGHTH BREACH

26. Section 13 of the NZ Bill of Rights Act provides that “Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience, religion and belief, including the right to adopt and to hold opinions without interference.”
27. The Police grabbed Mrs Raue out of the crowd after the political meeting had ended. Two burly Policemen grabbed her and manhandled her out of the building, pushed her across the back of the Police car and handcuffed this five foot six inch tall, eight stone, nearly 50 year old woman.
28. These bullying tactics against a known political activist, present at a public meeting to express her view along with everyone else, albeit in a forthright manner, clearly interfered with her Right to freedom of thought and belief and her right to hold those opinions and to express them at the public meeting called to discuss the viability of a $4,000,000 community ‘facility’ for a small provincial town which is already well served with such facilities, against which proposal Mrs Raue was a known campaigner. That the Masterton Police assisted in the attempt to silence her criticism of the proposed scheme, by arresting her without sufficient investigation, is a clear breach of this Right.

NINTH BREACH

29. The above comments expressed in paragraph 28 apply equally to the further breach by the Masterton Police of her Right under Section 14 of the NZ Bill of Rights Act, namely that “Everyone has the right to freedom of expression, including the freedom to seek, receive and impart information and opinions of any kind, in any form.”
30. The treatment of Mrs Raue by the Masterton Police, and their complicit behaviour with the organizers of the public meeting to attempt to silence Mrs Raue was outrageous.
31. The local District Council proposed to spend $4,000,000 on a major community project which would, inevitably, result in large increases in rates as a consequence. Mrs Raue had every right to be at the political meeting and to express her views, and the behaviour of the Police that night clearly interfered with this Right. In fact, it breached nearly every combination and permutation of this Right in that the Police were complicit in the attempt to silence her, and to terminate her Right, i.e. - the Right to express herself freely on the matter, - the Right to seek information as to the proposed project, - the Right to receive any information pertaining to the proposed project, - the Right to impart her own opinions as to the wisdom or otherwise of the proposal, and - the Right to impart her own information as to the viability of the project.

TENTH BREACH

32. Section 16 of the NZ Bill of Rights Act provides that “Everyone has the right to peaceful assembly.”
33. The Masterton Police had been forewarned that Mrs Raue might attend that public meeting and make her views known. She had every right to be there, according to the Right of peaceful assembly. Her treatment at the hands of the Police clearly infringed on this Right.

ELEVENTH BREACH

34. Section 17 of the NZ Bill of Rights Act provides that “Everyone has the right to freedom of association.”
35. A number of Mrs Raue’s supporters attended the public meeting. Many other concerned citizens attended the meeting. Some were for the proposal, some were against it, but Mrs Raue is assured under the Act of the Right of freedom to associate with other equally public spirited citizen, to gather together with them to discuss common social concerns, proposed public projects that will impact on the citizens’ future rates, to discuss the merits or otherwise of major public facilities, use of public resources, etc.
36. The actions of the Masterton Police following the break up of the public meeting clearly breached Mrs Raue’s Right to associate with her fellow citizens and to debate with them about public issues that affect them all. The violent manner in which they interfered with this Right compounds the seriousness of their breach of Mrs Raue’s Right of freedom of association.

TWELFTH BREACH

37. When the Police stopped Mrs Raue from leaving the meeting (which had finished) and going home, when they grabbed her out of the crowd, when they dragged her out to the Police car, and when they pushed her face down over the boot of the car and handcuffed her, they quite clearly interfered with her Right to “freedom of movement”, a Right guaranteed under Section 18 of the NZ Bill of Rights Act.

THIRTEENTH BREACH

38. Section 21 of the NZ Bill of Rights Act provides that “Everyone has the right to be secure against unreasonable search or seizure, whether of the person, property ……. or otherwise.”
39. There appear to have been several breaches of this Section. The first was clearly when the Police seized Mrs Raue at the public meeting, and took her away to spend the night in the Masterton Police Station following the public meeting, without actually arresting her or advising her of the reason for the alleged arrest.

FOURTEENTH BREACH

40. The next breach of her right not to be unreasonably searched was when the police were processing Mrs Raue at the Masterton Police Station when three Police Officers (clearly visible on the Police Station CCTV video presently in the possession of the Masterton District Court as Evidence) all piled on top of Mrs Raue in an attempt to detach from her, her pounamu taonga, while another Police Officer approached her with a pair of scissors, saying “It would be a shame if these scissors slipped and you lost an eye, wouldn’t it?”
41. There was absolutely no need whatsoever to force Mrs Raue to undergo such a search in such humiliating circumstances in an attempt to remove her necklace. It was totally unreasonable when one considers that Mrs Raue should have been processed straight away (there was nobody else being processed in the Station at the time), she should have been released immediately on Police Bail, and she should have been allowed to go home with her friend who was waiting for her in the public waiting area next door to the cell block.
42. There was no reason to think that Mrs Raue would do herself harm; it would not have been reasonable to suspect that she might harm anyone else, i.e. that she might, perhaps, garrotte a Police Officer with it, with five or six Police Officers milling around her and behind the public counter…... It was a quite gratuitous and public humiliation instead, and this search of her involving the attempted forcible removal of her pounamu taonga was manifestly unreasonable, and resulted in their ripping Mrs Raue’s blouse in the process.
43. The removal, and the manner of the removal, of the pounamu necklace showed an appalling lack of sensitivity to Mrs Raue’s cultural background. The pounamu necklace is a taonga, or treasure, of strong cultural significance to Mrs Raue. The cross cultural communication skills of the Masterton Police are well below the standard expected.

FIFTEENTH BREACH

44. And then there was the strip search of Mrs Raue, with Police Officers taking off her bra and peering inside her panties and pulling them down. Mrs Raue was mortified, and this search was, again, an unreasonable breach of her Right against unreasonable search, when one reflects on the alleged offences with which she was later charged the following day, just prior to going to Court at about 10.30 a.m. namely Trespass, Disorderly Behaviour and Resisting Arrest (and two charges of assault which were apparently a result of defending herself against the illegal strip search and removal of her necklace, defending her Right to freedom from unreasonable search and seizure).
45. Again, Mrs Raue should have been just charged immediately at the Police Station when she was taken there and processed promptly in the public area before being released promptly on bail. There was no need to take her into a cell (outside the range of the video cameras …..) and strip search her.
46. This unreasonable strip search, during which her blouse was further ripped, as can be seen on the video, once again breached her Right to be secure against unreasonable search.

SIXTEENTH BREACH

47. In fact this wrestling to the floor by the three or four burly Police Officers, in an attempt to cut off her necklace, and the comment by the Police Officer that she might lose an eye, actually constitute another breach of the Right prohibiting “torture, as well as “cruel and degrading treatment”, pursuant to Section 9 of the NZ Bill of Rights Act.

SEVENTEENTH BREACH

48. And the further subsequent incident involving the forcible strip search, and further ripping of Mrs Raue’s blouse in the Police cell constitute a separate and distinguishable further breach of the protection of Section 9 of the NZ Bill of Rights Act, which prohibits cruel or degrading treatment.

EIGHTEENTH BREACH

49. The arbitrary manner in which the Masterton Police seized Mrs Raue has clearly broken one of the cardinal human rights, set out in Section 22 of the NZ Bill of Rights Act, that “Everyone has the right not to be arbitrarily arrested or detained.”
50. The Masterton Police ‘arrested’ Mrs Raue at the close of the political meeting arbitrarily. They arrested no one else in spite of numerous onlookers, not just Mrs Raue’s associates, protesting at the actions of the police in their violent and cavalier treatment of Mrs Raue.
51. The District Court Judge made clear his concerns at the actions of the local Police force in effecting this ‘arrest’ in his Judgment, when dismissing the three charges relating to the offences allegedly committed at the hall, at the close of the case for the Prosecution.
52. And his unusual Order that the Police pay legal costs of $3781 towards Mrs Raue’s actual legal costs is indicative of his concern at the Police’s treatment of Mrs Raue at the point of the alleged arrest, and that she was not advised at the time of the reasons for her ‘arrest’.

NINTEENTH BREACH

53. Moreover, when Mrs Raue was taken to the Masterton Police Station and detained overnight, there was an obvious spirit of punishment by the Police, and of teaching Mrs Raue a lesson for her behaviour, rather than on any principled basis of ‘process her and let her go home’ (with her companion who was waiting next door).
54. The Police did not even process Mrs Raue by fingerprinting her and photographing her until the next morning. They knew Mrs Raue well, and the Evidence shows that Mrs Raue asked repeatedly to be charged, and processed and released on Police Bail.
55. The Police could have merely bailed her in the evening and told her to come back in the morning to face what charges they thought she might face after a proper investigation. Instead they arbitrarily detained Mrs Raue overnight, even though her companion waited next door until well after midnight to transport her home to Carterton.
56. This cavalier and arbitrary approach to Mrs Raue’s right not to be arbitrarily detained appears to have had no other reason but to teach her a lesson. She was not intoxicated, she was of no danger to herself or others, and she could have been quite easily processed on the spot at the Police Station, or told to come back in the morning.
57. The political meeting was well and truly over. To keep Mrs Raue in behind bars overnight was a serious breach of her Right not to be arbitrarily detained, and this behaviour by the Masterton Police is of utmost concern.

TWENTIETH BREACH

58. Section 23(1)(a) of the NZ Bill of Rights Act provides that “Everyone who is arrested …… shall be informed at the time of the arrest of the reason for it.”
59. Judge Behrens made it quite clear in his Judgment dismissing the charges of Trespass, Disorderly, Behaviour and Resisting Arrest, that he was most dissatisfied with the situation and arresting procedures carried out by the Masterton Police at the close of the political meeting at the hall.
60. Mrs Raue has given the most emphatic instructions to myself that she was never told what she was being arrested for when the Police grabbed her and hustled her off to be pushed over the boot of the Police car and handcuffed. She advises that she did not know what charges were being laid against her until the following morning (just before she went into Court at 10:30 a.m. the next day) when she was fingerprinted and photographed
61. It therefore appears that Mrs Raue’s Rights in this regard have been breached. Certainly the Masterton Police’s non-compliance with their duties and responsibilities in this area was of considerable concern to Judge Behrens Q.C. as can be seen in his Judgment.

TWENTYFIRST BREACH

62. The next breach by the Masterton Keystone Kops appears to have been their blatant disregard of the cornerstone of justice for centuries, contained in Section 23(b) of the NZ Bill of Rights Act, which provides that “Everyone who is arrested shall have the right to consult and instruct a lawyer without delay and shall be informed of that right.”
63. Mrs Raue had asked to speak to her lawyer Mr Ken Daniels in the Police car while being taken to the Masterton Police Station, following the first Bill Of Rights warning given to her in the Police car.
64. She was, however, not allowed to ring Mr Daniels until well after she got to the station, following the attempted unreasonable seizure of her necklace and the unreasonable strip search, during which both searches she was physically (wo)manhandled and physically restrained in brutal and quite unnecessarily degrading circumstances.
65. She was, in fact, not allowed to contact her lawyer until well after the disgraceful treatment meted out to her at the Masterton Police Station. She should have been allowed to ring Mr Daniels as soon as she arrived at the police Station in Masterton.
66. Mrs Raue constantly requested to talk to Mr Daniels, but the Police refused to allow her to contact him until after she had been ‘processed’, which processing that night extended only as to the violent removal of her necklace and her underwear, and ripping her blouse on two separate occasions, but not, apparently to the usual processes of photographing, fingerprinting, laying of charges and arranging Police Bail for Mrs Raue. The Masterton Police chose to delay these procedures and processes until the next day!
67. For the Masterton Police to proceed with the unreasonable searches and seizures of Mrs Raue and to strip search her over her protestations that she wanted to talk to her lawyer, a mere phone call away, is indicative of either a cynical and conscious disregard for Mrs Raue’s Right to talk to her lawyer without delay after she was ‘arrested’ at the public hall, or an appallingly negligent or reckless ignorance as to what is an expected level of Police awareness that they should allow an arrested person to consult, as well as instruct, a lawyer without delay, once that person is arrested, i.e. at the Hall, not after the Police deign to allow this consultation, either at the convenience of the Police, or at their whim.
68. The Masterton Police Officers present that night need urgent reminders as to their duties and responsibilities regarding the Rights of arrested persons to consult their lawyers without delay.

TWENTYSECOND BREACH

69. Section 23(2) of the NZ Bill of Rights Act provides that “Everyone who is arrested for an offence has the right to be charged promptly.” Mrs Raue has instructed me that she was not actually charged with any offenses until the morning after she was taken into custody and kept overnight in the Masterton Police cells.
70. It should be possible during the investigation of the breaches to obtain written evidence from the Masterton Police Station records regarding these incidents, as to the exact time that Mrs Raue was charged with the five alleged offences, and this will, no doubt establish whether or not the Police’s own records indicate if there has been a breach of this right or not. These Documents were not discovered to the Defense during the criminal trials, but I have had information furnished to me in other cases where the Police record at what time the actual charges are laid. One would hope that the Police Complaints Authority has the power to force the Masterton Police to produce such evidence if it is available.

TWENTYTHIRD BREACH

71. In his Judgment dismissing the last two charges of assault and assaulting Police at the close of the case for the Prosecution, following submissions from myself as to the numerous breaches of human rights that appeared to have been committed by the Masterton Police officers, and after watching the Police video, Judge Behrens Q.C. made clear his distaste for the behaviour of the Masterton Police at the Police Station, as well as having expressed concerns in his earlier Judgment as the behaviour of the Masterton Police during the situation at the Carterton Municipal Hall (again at the close of the case for the Prosecution, following submissions from myself as to the numerous breaches of human Rights that appeared to have been committed by the Masterton Police officers).
72. The behaviour of the Masterton Police officers clearly breached the duty pursuant to Section 23(5) of the NZ Bill of Rights Act stating “That everyone deprived of liberty shall be treated with humanity and with respect for the inherent dignity of the person.”
73. Mrs Raue was most certainly not treated with dignity by the Police, and in no way did the Police treat her with respect for her inherent dignity, from the very first contact with her, to the last humiliating and vindictive actions of refusing to allow her companion, who was waiting for her in the foyer of the Police Station to give her her handbag containing her toiletries, heart medication and personal effects. This was not just mean-minded and mean-spirited, but an actual breach of Mrs Raue’s Right to be treated humanely, with humanity, and with dignity.
74. Judge Behrens rightly scolded the Masterton Police for their behaviour, but the litany of breaches suggests surely that the standard of respect for basic human rights amongst the Masterton Police must be amongst the lowest in the country. Urgent retraining of the local Police seems to be called for to correct this situation which currently exists in Masterton.

TWENTYFOURTH BREACH

75. Amongst the Rights of persons actually charged, is the right under Section 24(a) of the NZ Bill of Rights Act “to be informed promptly and in detail of the nature and cause of the charge”. As stated earlier in paragraph 68, Mrs Raue has indicated that she was not informed of the charges until the morning after she was ‘arrested’ and detained overnight. This is a clear breach of the Right to be informed promptly of the nature and cause of the charge.

TWENTYFIFTH BREACH

76. By detaining Mrs Raue in the Masterton cells overnight, the Masterton Police have clearly breached the right under Section 24(2) of the NZ Bill of Rights Act, “to be released on reasonable terms and conditions unless there is just cause for continued detention.”
77. One of the Police Officers cross-examined by myself during the trial, Suzanne Mackle, admitted that Kate Raue was not bailed and released that night because of her alleged “poor behaviour”, which seemed to comprise the apparently bad behaviour, according to the Police’s evidence, of continually asking to consult her lawyer!”
78. No just cause was ever advanced by the local Police as to why they kept Mrs Raue overnight in gaol, and their breach of her right to be released on reasonable terms and conditions (perhaps, for example, to present herself the following day for further questioning) was arrogant, punitive, vindictive, and deserving of strong censure by the Police Complaints Authority.

TWENTYSIXTH BREACH

79. The Police contend that they ‘arrested’ Mrs Raue for trespass and disorderly behaviour, but the District Court took the view that the arrest was illegal. Nevertheless, once the Police believed themselves to have arrested her, they were under the obligation, pursuant to Section 24(c)of the NZ Bill of Rights Act to ensure that Mrs Raue was able to exercise her Right “to consult and instruct a lawyer.”
80. But the Masterton Police did not allow her to exercise that right until towards the end of their dispensing their own particular brand of summary justice, which was horrifyingly recorded on their own video camera. The video is most alarming in its revelations as to the inability of the Masterton Police to deal with the volatile situation that developed, in a professional and calming way. They were supposed to be the professionals. They are supposed to be trained in preventing situations from escalating. Their conduct that night fell far short of that expected of Police officers, who should be trained to calm situations, rather than inflame them, surely?

TWENTYSEVENTH BREACH

81. It is clear that the Police gave their trip between the Masterton Police Station and the Carterton Municipal Hall a “Priority One” status. Evidence was presented that the trip was completed in seven minutes, under flashing lights and sirens, which haste and manner of traveling attracted the condemnation of Judge Behrens.
82. It is apparent from their conduct from the beginning that they totally ignored the fundamental Right pursuant to Section 25(c) of the NZ Bill of Rights Act, the Right “to be presumed innocent until proved guilty according to law.”
83. Police ignored the attempts of numerous bystanders to explain the situation.
84. See particularly the transcript of the email from Mr and Mrs Kennedy to Helen Clark, written that night, and the record by Mr Kennedy of his outrage at the way Mrs Raue was treated.
85. Mr Kennedy even returned to the Carterton Municipal Hall after going home, so that he could remonstrate with the organisers of the meeting as to their treatment of Mrs Raue.
86. He also had a half hour discussion the following day with Jack Johnson the Area Commander of the Masterton Police, to indicate his outrage at the brutal and over-the-top behaviour of the Police when they dragged Mrs Raue out of the hall.
87. The Masterton Police presumed Mrs Raue guilty from the start and gave no credence obviously to the presumption that she was innocent. This was a clear breach of the minimum standard expected in criminal procedures instituted by Police.
88. Mrs Raue was entitled to the presumption of ‘innocent until proven guilty according to law’, and the Police never applied that presumption to her situation.
89. Their preconception that she was guilty arose before the meeting even took place, as it came out during the trial that the organizers of the meeting had alerted the Masterton Police to the possibility that Kate Raue would probably be present, and it was arranged that the organisers would contact the Police should they feel that Mrs Raue was causing trouble.
90. So, Mrs Raue was hung, drawn and quartered as far as the local Police were concerned before there were even any alleged offences committed by her. Their attitude was that she was going to be guilty, whatever happened. Their perception before the meeting, and on the way to the Carterton Municipal Hall was that she was guilty (of whatever) until proven innocent.
91. This is a situation which mirrors Kafka’s ‘The Trial”, and should be disapproved in no uncertain terms, especially in a political milieu, which was the case here.
92. The latest Long Term Council Community Plan of the Carterton District Council, including the Financial Reports, and current financial projections regarding the current budget for the immediate future has been assessed by the Council’s Auditors as “unsatisfactory”, which would appear to confirm that Mrs Raue’s concerns (concerns which are also shared by the signatories of a relatively substantial petition) are valid.
93. Laurie Desborough of Audit New Zealand, on behalf of the Auditor General, Palmerston North, has determined in his Draft Report on the Carterton District Council’s Long Term Council Community Plan 2006-2016, incorporating the 2006/2007 Annual Plan, Volume 1 Finance and Strategy (‘the Plan’), on page 157 that “In our opinion, the Statement of Proposal for adoption of the LTCCP of the District Council, incorporating Volumes 1 to 2 dated 19 July 2006, does not provide a reasonable basis for long term integrated decision-making by the District Council and for participation in decision –making by the public and subsequent accountability to the community about the matters listed below: - “There is inadequate underlying information to support the forecast information included in the statement of Proposal. As a result, the forecasts of capital expenditure and operating expenditure, including the estimates of depreciation, could be materially misstated across all of the District Council’s activities. Also, because the forecast expenditure is not supported by adequate asset management plans, the District Council has been unable to demonstrate that the forecast expenditure will deliver the proposed levels of service across all the District Council’s activities. As a result, the information in the prospective financial statements is not supportable, and has not been based on the best information reasonably expected to be available to the District Council at the time of preparing the Statement of Proposal. This is also a departure from Financial Reporting Standard No. 42 (FRS-42): Prospective Financial Statements."
94. As well, on page 158 of the Plan, the Auditor General found that: “The District Council has not identified and adequately explained the sources of funds for its activities’ capital expenditure. The District Council does not operate separate activity level reserves, and some capital expenditure is funded from a general reserve, which is funded from various activities. This may result in surplus targeted rates in some activities being used to fund capital expenditure in other activities. “Based on the above, the District Council has been unable to demonstrate, as required by Section 101 of the Act, that it is managing its revenues, expenses, assets and liabilities, investments and general financial dealings prudently and in a manner that promotes the current and future interests of the community."
95. As well, on page 158, the officer of the Auditor General found that: “The District Council has not complied with the requirements of the Act, and has not demonstrated good practice for a Council of its size and scale within the context of the environment in respect of the following: As explained above, the District Council has been unable to demonstrate, as required by Section 101 of the Act, that it is managing its revenues, expenses, assets and liabilities, investments and general financial dealings prudently and in a manner that promotes the current and future interests of the community.” “The underlying information used to prepare the Statement of Proposal is inadequate and does not provide a reasonable basis for the preparation of the forecast information, as explained above."

96. Furthermore, page 159 of the Plan shows that the Auditor General found that: “The financial information is not presented in accordance with generally accepted accounting practice in New Zealand, in that: As explained above the information in the prospective financial statements is not supportable, and has not been based on the best information reasonably expected to be available to the District Council at the time of preparing the Statement of Proposal. This is a departure from FRS-42. As explained above, the forecast expenditure is not supported by adequate underlying information, and the District Council has been unable to demonstrate that the forecast expenditure will deliver the proposed levels of service. Consequently the extent to which the forecast information and proposed performance measures provide an appropriate framework for the meaningful assessment of the actual levels of service provision does not reflect good practice for a Council of its size and scale within the context of its environment."
97. As well, the Auditor General found that: “the scope of our work was limited as we were unable to obtain sufficient information about the underlying information to support the forecast information included in the Statement of Proposal.”

98. Mrs Raue’s concerns about the viability of the proposed $4,000,000 community facility appear to be well founded. According to the Auditor General, the standard of performance of the Carterton District Council’s financial affairs is extremely poor; in fact, they appear to be in a very sorry state indeed.
99. Pages 11 and 12 of the Council’s LTCCP refer to the Council’s commitment to the proposal.
100. On page 12 of the LTCCP, the Council (who also, coincidentally, mainly comprise the members of the ‘Focus Group’ behind the $4,000,000 proposal) “seeks your views on contributing $1 million to this project."
101. The second paragraph on page 12 of the LTCCP states that: “Should the community support the concept,” the Council would agree to make a commitment of one million dollars towards the cost of this ‘facility’, and goes on to state: “Council seeks the views of the community as to whether you believe that this investment is important for the future of our district.”
102. Also referred to on page 12 of the LTCCP is the Council’s alleged commitment to the consultation process, although the events at the public meeting which led to Mrs Raue’s unlawful detention make a mockery of this document, and of the Council’s commitment to the consultation process.
103. The actions of the local Police in trying to shut Mrs Raue up, and to silence her questioning of the need for an expensive white elephant in the community is an intolerable intrusion into Mrs Raue’s political rights to involve herself into the debate by the local community as to the wisdom or otherwise of this community facility.
104. The behaviour of the Masterton Police towards Mrs Raue, and their numerous and serious breaches of her human rights, guaranteed under the NZ Bill of Rights Act, deserve the most serious investigation by the Police Complaints Authority, and consideration given to awarding her financial compensation for each and every one of these breaches.
105. As well, she is entitled to recompense for the legal fees she has incurred as a consequence of the blatant and cavalier disregard of these rights
106. The harassment of Mrs Raue was continued by the Masterton Police when they also charged her with disorderly behaviour for her alleged conduct in the local library, when she was attempting to obtain material relevant to the $4,000,000 proposal, from the Library, which was advertised as the contact point for material about the proposed facility.
107. Judge Goddard, on appeal, acquitted Mrs Raue of that charge and indicated that her behaviour certainly did not require the intervention of the criminal law.
108. But the Masterton Police, in laying the charge, and its pursuit of Mrs Raue, have resulted in Mrs Raue’s incurring further legal fees of $5,000 in defending the charge in the first instance, and then on the successful appeal to the High Court (which did not allow costs for the successful appeal).
109. The participation in the democratic process by civic-minded citizens such as Mrs Raue is to be applauded. Without the fearless questioning of local body officials by such citizens, who are prepared to stand up and be counted, the days of vigorous and healthy political debates would be numbered.
110. The bullying and intimidatory tactics of the Masterton Police that night were a disgrace to the New Zealand Police Force as a whole.
111. When Mrs Raue uttered her cri-de-coeur for help to Mr Rodney Hide, he expressed his concern that her upcoming trial was a serious constitutional matter, that it raised fundamental human rights issues, such as freedom of speech, in a so-called democratic society. He was right. Mr Daniels also expressed his concern to the Masterton Police about their insistence on continuing with these (politically motivated) charges.
112. It was fortunate for Mrs Raue that Judge Behrens Q.C. took an equally vigorous approach in his Judgments, upholding Mrs Raue’s human rights, and, dismissing all of the five charges laid against her, at the close of the cases for the Prosecution, the evidence presented by them, as they admitted, being “tenuous”.
113. Mrs Raue and I look forward to hearing from you in due course.
Yours faithfully,

Michael Appleby

LIST OF ATTACHED DOCUMENTS

1. Letter from Police Complaints Authority dated 9 December 2005
2. Formal Complaint regarding Katherine Raue
3. Decision of Behrens J regarding charges of Trespass, Disorderly Behaviour and Resisting Arrest
4. Decision of Behrens J regarding charges of Assault and Assaulting a Police Officer
5. Bill of Costs
6. Application for Costs, including:
7. Submissions regarding Costs,
8. Submissions of the Police Opposing Costs,
9. Submissions in Reply to the Police Submissions in Opposition,
10. Decision of Behrens J regarding Application for Costs.
11. Decsion of Goddard J
12. Letter from Ken Daniels to the Police dated 26 August 2004
13. E-mail response to Ken Daniels from the Police dated 26 April 2006
14. Carterton District Council LCTTP Plan.