Here's the latest damning report on the South End School:
South End School
3 August 2010
To the Parents and Community of South End School:
This review evaluates the extent and effectiveness of actions the school has taken towards addressing issues specified in the previous review and/or any additional areas identified since that review.
The Education Review Office [ERO] evaluation of South End School follows.
South End School is a Year 1 to 8 primary school located in Carterton in the Wairarapa. Two Montessori classes successfully operate as part of the school.
ERO’s April 2008 education review identified many areas requiring attention. These included self review, the quality of professional leadership, curriculum management, consistency of assessment, teaching, planning and processes for reporting to parents. The supplementary review report of May 2009 identified progress in some areas but improvement was still required in: self review; professional leadership and school culture; curriculum and performance management; and provision for students with particular learning needs. This 2010 review evaluates progress made in addressing these concerns.
Teachers collaborate to share good practice. Individually they use effective teaching strategies and meaningful learning activities. Positive and affirming relationships are apparent in all classrooms. Students demonstrate good self‑management skills. They are well engaged in their learning.
Teachers have a planned approach to monitoring students’ progress and achievement, supported by the special needs coordinator (SENCO). Students at risk of not achieving at expectations for their age are identified through achievement data. Targeted education plans are developed to include appropriate interventions for these students.
Staff show an increasing confidence in teaching te reo Māori and integrating aspects of te ao Māori into classroom programmes. They are supported by a Board of Trustees’ member who has strong links with local iwi. Staff and management commitment to catering for the needs of Māori students is clearly evident.
The principal has attended to some aspects of managing achievement information and hazard identification. However, curriculum and professional leadership are still of concern. The principal continues to require considerable support to address issues related to curriculum review, the implementation of The New Zealand Curriculum, staff performance management and clear communication with staff on professional and management matters.
ERO recommends that the Secretary for Education consider intervention in order to address the issues identified in this report.
Future Action:
ERO intends to carry out another review within a year.
Review Coverage:
When ERO has reviewed a school we encourage boards to inform their community of any follow-up action they plan to do. You should talk to the board or principal if you have any questions about this evaluation, the full ERO report or their future intentions.
If you would like a copy of the full report, please contact the school or see the ERO website, http://www.ero.govt.nz.
Kathleen Atkins
National Manager Review Services
Central Region
1 Background
Confirmed education Review Report:
South End School
Introduction
The confirmed Education Review Office (ERO) review of South End School May 2009 signalled a return review within 12 months.
This review evaluates the extent and effectiveness of actions the school has taken towards addressing issues specified in the previous review and/or any additional areas identified since that review.
This review report was prepared in accordance with standard procedures approved by the Chief Review Officer.
Terms of Reference
This review is based on an evaluation of the performance of the South End School Board of Trustees and management in relation to areas identified in the May 2009 ERO report or issues identified since that review.
The terms of reference for this review are to investigate:
self review, including use of achievement information in curriculum self review;
how effective the school has been in developing a culture of professional trust;
curriculum management;
progress in implementing The New Zealand Curriculum;
consistency in implementing the performance management system;
educational leadership;
provision for students with special learning needs;
the achievement of Māori students;
how the school identifies and provides for gifted and talented students; and
any further matters that may impact negatively on student safety, achievement or the sustainability of the school.
2 The Education Review Office (ERO) Evaluation
South End School is a Year 1 to 8 primary school located in Carterton in the Wairarapa. Two Montessori classes successfully operate as part of the school.
ERO’s April 2008 education review identified many areas requiring attention. These included self review, the quality of professional leadership, curriculum management, consistency of assessment, teaching, planning and processes for reporting to parents. The supplementary review report of May 2009 identified progress in some areas but improvement was still required in: self review; professional leadership and school culture; curriculum and performance management; and provision for students with particular learning needs. This 2010 review evaluates progress made in addressing these concerns.
Teachers collaborate to share good practice. Individually they use effective teaching strategies and meaningful learning activities. Positive and affirming relationships are apparent in all classrooms. Students demonstrate good self‑management skills. They are well engaged in their learning.
Teachers have a planned approach to monitoring students’ progress and achievement, supported by the special needs coordinator (SENCO). Students at risk of not achieving at expectations for their age are identified through achievement data. Targeted education plans are developed to include appropriate interventions for these students.
Staff show an increasing confidence in teaching te reo Māori and integrating aspects of te ao Māori into classroom programmes. They are supported by a Board of Trustees’ member who has strong links with local iwi. Staff and management commitment to catering for the needs of Māori students is clearly evident.
The principal has attended to some aspects of managing achievement information and hazard identification. However, curriculum and professional leadership are still of concern. The principal continues to require considerable support to address issues related to curriculum review, the implementation of The New Zealand Curriculum, staff performance management and clear communication with staff on professional and management matters.
ERO recommends that the Secretary for Education consider intervention in order to address the issues identified in this report.
Future Action:
ERO intends to carry out another review within a year.
3 Findings
Context and Background
ERO’s April 2008 education review identified a variety of areas requiring attention. These included self review, the quality of professional leadership, curriculum management, variability in assessment, teaching, planning and processes for reporting to parents. The supplementary review report of May 2009 identified progress in some of these areas but improvement was still required in self review, professional leadership and culture, curriculum and performance management and provision for students with particular learning needs. This report evaluates progress made in addressing these concerns.
The principal developed an action plan to address areas requiring further improvement. An outside facilitator worked with the staff, principal and board to improve communication and trust between these groups. A plan for a mentor to support the principal in developing curriculum management and leadership skills was not implemented.
At the time of this review a new board had recently been elected and includes three experienced members from the previous board.
Areas of progress
Collaborative culture
Teachers work together collaboratively to share good practice. This extends to interchange of ideas between mainstream and Montessori teachers. Students from both areas of the school participate in a number of joint activities. Staff and trustees consider that their relationships with each other are positive.
Managing achievement information
The principal has developed a framework for the timing of assessments across the school with some guidelines for administering standardised tests. He has developed a schedule for reporting an appropriate range of student achievement information to the board in literacy and numeracy. Trustees receive information that identifies numbers of students who are achieving below expectations and strategies to address these gaps. The board states that it is better informed about school-wide achievement through improved presentation, analysis and commentary on information that the principal provides.
Catering for special learning needs
Students at risk of not achieving are identified from achievement data. Targeted education plans include appropriate interventions for identified students. Progress is closely monitored by the class teachers and SENCO. The board receives reports on the impact of these interventions.
Clearly defined criteria identify those who are gifted and talented and extension and enrichment opportunities are made available through external providers.
Māori achievement
Māori students make appropriate progress over time in reading, writing and numeracy. While some are represented in the underachievement data, others achieve at and above expectations for their chronological age. The school maintains regular dialogue with Māori whānau, consulting and sharing outcomes of achievement targets. Staff show an increasing confidence in providing teaching of te reo Māori and integrating aspects of te ao Māori into classroom programmes, supported by a trustee who has strong links with local iwi. Staff and management commitment to catering for the needs of Māori students is clearly evident.
Areas for further improvement
The principal has addressed some issues related to management systems, including hazard identification. The lack of school-wide curriculum and professional leadership remains a concern. The principal continues to require considerable support to provide the leadership to address the following issues:
Curriculum review
While there is a schedule for assessment and reporting achievement to the board, curriculum review and development are not planned. Teachers individually use achievement data to plan programmes but no collation is done to inform school curriculum review.
The school has made limited progress in reviewing its curriculum to ensure it meets the requirements of The New Zealand Curriculum (NZC), and therefore the National Administration Guidelines (1). In 2008 the board established its values as part of a charter revision. In 2010 staff developed essence statements for curriculum areas. Some teachers independently implement aspects of NZC in their classrooms. As yet there are no curriculum guidelines that express expectations for teaching NZC.
Performance management
Variability in implementation of the performance management system continues. Provisionally registered teachers (PRTs) are provided with a consistent and comprehensive programme of support and guidance. The principal’s appraisal cycle has begun with assistance from an external education professional. However, the appraisal process was only partially completed for most teachers in 2009 and, apart from the provision of job descriptions and the PRT programme, the process for 2010 has yet to start.
Communication
The principal has established a senior management team but there is no evidence that this has improved communication with the staff as whole. Clear expectations for teachers and direction for the school as a learning community have not been communicated to staff.
4 Action Required
The board of trustees must ensure that:
4.1 performance appraisal for all teaching staff is completed each year.
[Section 77C State Sector Act 1988]
5 Recommendations to Other Agencies
ERO recommends that:
5.1 the Secretary for Education consider intervention under Part 7A of the Education Act 1989 in order to address the issues identified in this report.
6 Future Action
ERO intends to carry out another review within a year.
Kathleen Atkins
National Manager Review Services
Central Region
The 2011 report is here, and more information, which ERO has chosen to ignore, is also on this site.
Tuesday, August 3, 2010
South End School ERO report 2010:
Labels:
ERO,
south end school
Wednesday, July 28, 2010
Update on the corrupt charges against me, and how your taxes are being wasted:
Today was my birthday, and I had to go all the way to Wellington District Court to answer the latest corrupt charges laid against me by the useless and corrupt Wairarapa police. Perverting the Course of Justice and Escaping Custody. What a joke! I didn't pervert the course of justice, it is indisputably obvious that the matter is an abuse of process and a complete and utter waste of taxpayers money, the Crown case is an orchestrated litany of lies that anyone can see through, Michael Murphy and Aaron Brook are two of the least credible witnesses it would be possible to find, and it is indisputably obvious that the Wairarapa police have been perverting the course of justice for at least eight years, and a lot longer by all accounts:
Specifically, local police have repeatedly refused to investigate the following (inter alia):
- the illegal takeover, mismanagement and closure of the Carterton Community Centre, after the Secretary and Treasurer was punched in the face and the locks on the building were changed to cover up the fraud going on there - these allegation are supported by letters from at least five lawyers and are published on this site (links up soon),
- Police refuse to charge Georgina Beyer with with conspiring to defeat justice by writing an official letter denying that there was fraud at the Carterton Community Centre, involving people associated with the District Council - that's the reason Beyer resigned from parliament.
- Police refuse to charge Gary McPhee and his mate for the drunken, violent home invasion and assault which he boasted about in the paper, establishing a clear and indisputable prima facie case
- Police refuse to charge Tracy Lee with the theft of $500 from a local woman and making a false statement to police regarding a phone call she told police that she received from my address,
- Police refuse to charge Michael Francis Murphy with the attack on me in my home on the 11th February 2010.
The last police perversion of justice listed above is one of the most blatant of all and involves none other than Michael Murphy and his mate, drunken lout of an illegally elected Mayor, Gary McPhee, and corrupt local Constable Peter Cletoris Cunningham. Murphy incited other people to join him in driving to my home to commit a violent attack that was witnessed by at least three other people who all called 111 immediately and described the attack in graphic terms as it was taking place. One of the witnesses eventually intervened with a dog, which stopped the attack and caused the offenders to leave.
Police accuse me of making the whole thing up, and say that even if it were true, it was ok for them to come and violently attack me - because I allegedly took a five year old child to the supermarket without the permission of its mother! First they tried to say I left the child alone in the supermarket and the child was distressed, until I requested the CCTV footage, which has never been provided of course, because it showed that the child was not neglected or distressed. The story changed then, to the one about taking the child without permission. Anyone knows that if a mother has concerns about her child she should go to the police, not go and smash down the person's door and assault them in a blind rage. Concerns of serious abuse are one thing, but taking a child to the supermarket without permission is quite another and certainly does not warrant a violent attack!
Anyway, I went all the way to Wellington District Court to defend myself on the charges, after the corrupt lawyers and amicus curiae repeatedly refuse to assist me to fill in any applications for Disclosure, for example, which should have been provided months ago under the Privacy Act and the Official Information Act and only worry about how much money they can suck up for dragging the proceedings out as long as possible. True to form, the case did not go ahead today, it was a waste of everyone's time - how much did Bryan Yeoman get paid for that?! What an utter creep he is! I was imprisoned for two days illegally because of him!
On arrival, I was handed this: (Click on the images to enlarge them)



The Judge said there wouldn't be time to hear the matter, which was odd, because there we were, at the appointed time, and the whole floor of the Court building - 3 Courtrooms, offices, etc, was completely deserted, so it didn't look like they were very busy with any other cases at all.
Constable Laura Rhymer didn't turn up for the hearing of the Crown application because she knew perfectly well that she did NOT arrest me because I had not committed any crime. Constable Rhymer didn't turn up for the hearing on the 8th December, because she applied for annual leave just two days before the hearing. Corrupt Constable Cunningham and his corrupt fellow officers now expect Constable Laura Rhymer to lie, to put her whole career on the line by going along with his orchestrated litany of lies. She can't do it. What they want her to say is not true. I don't think she will convince anyone if she tries to lie about it, either. Read the story below by Ross Meurant (I know, I can't believe I said that either!) to see that corruption is common in the New Zealand police. It's getting a lot worse fast, too. The so called inquiry into the PCA by Margaret Bazely was a joke, and a waste of time and money, because it only focussed on sexual misconduct, when clearly the problem was far deeper, as evidenced by the imprisonment of John Dewar - the huge cover up was the real issue, not the sexual misconduct.
Here's the thing the amicus curiae tried to make me sign, agreeing that Constable Rhymer not give evidence in person - and the Court should just take her word for it that she arrested me! What rubbish! I hadn't done anything and she knew it!
This is how your taxes are being spent, while a Judge recently highlighted the hundreds of uninvestigated child abuse cases, and general incompetence and dysfunction of the Wairarapa police. More evidence of that is all over this site, and plenty of others too (links up soon).
I asked (among other things,) for a Court Order for the audiotape of the calls to 111 regarding Murphy's attack , which Murphy denied committing in his Depositions Evidence. The Judge refused my request. What outrageous corruption! He told me to make an application under the Disclosure Act or something for it, and then told me I should have instructed lawyer Noel Sainsbury to do it. I told him I HAD instructed him to do it, and he had refused to accept any of my instructions at all, including this one. I also told the Judge that I had requested it, and other evidence, which should have been provided months ago, under the Privacy Act and the Official Information Act.
The Judge wasn't interested, it was wink wink, nudge nudge with the corrupt amicus curiae, prosecutor, lawyers, and all the other slimy weasels that suck up our money from the gravy train, let's go home and write up our bills, ha ha, sickening really. It cost me $60 to get to Court with a support person - I have no lawyer. I must say that the Court security staff are very pleasant and helpful though. So anyway, it's been remanded till 30 September 2010 with absolutely RIDICULOUS - not to mention ILLEGAL - bail conditions - oh, that was something else I asked to speak to the Judge about, another request that was denied! More about the bail address soon, it's bedtime now.
Thank you to all the people who sent me happy birthday wishes and good wishes and offers of assistance for Court today, your kindness is appreciated so much, and I did have a lovely day cycling around my favorite city - I just love Wellington! I also made some nice new friends, including two lovely ladies called Karen and Viv who are a real credit to the Salvation Army, brightening up the day of everyone in the store with their friendly, happy, caring manner.
Labels:
Court,
laura rhymer,
murphy,
police
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
Ross Meurant Tells It Like It Is - An Inside View of the NZ Police:
This is cut and pasted directly from www.kiwisfirst.com only because I couldn't make a link to it directly, and with much appreciated permission from the editor of that site, Vince Siemer.
(I cannot believe I am actually agreeing with Ross Meurant after all these years, never mind giving him valuable space on my site! Shows how out of touch we are sometimes. Or maybe, how we're all not really that far apart, deep down.)
1:30 am, Court tomorrow, must be past my bedtime. Greatly relieved to see that I am not imagining that there is corruption within the ranks of the New Zealand Police.
FORMER TOP COP REFLECTS ON HIS OWN POLICE CULTURE EXPERIENCE IN CLAIMS NEW TERROR LAWS ARE THREAT TO CIVIL LIBERTIES
DEEP IN THE FOREST by Ross Meurant, B.A. M.P.P.
Like most recruits, I entered the police as an impressionable young man with a basic education, from a working class environment in provincial New Zealand. There were hundreds of peers like me, before me and after. I was nothing special but I was altruistic. We were all cannon fodder. Easy to manipulate. We looked at the forest before us in awe.
The moment you step into the police, this sub culture within NZ culture hits you. You are immediately part of the thin blue line. You are part of a team and that team looks after itself. You are special. You are the border between good and evil. The attitudes of the police instructors, armed not with teaching certificates but with ten years exposure to the police sub culture, either consciously or subconsciously invite you into the forest.
To step out of police college is to take the next step into the forest. You are now part of the difference between law and order in the streets where gangs would rule and evil would triumph. But for you and your fellow coppers, society would be a dangerous place. Your mission is to protect society from this evil. Very soon you learn to decide what is evil and what is not. You are no longer just a collector of human rubbish at the base of the cliff but you have an obligation; yes, even a duty to guide the country to a decent society. That direction is best decided by you and others in your sub culture of police, for what better epitomizes the values of a decent society than those cherished by the men and women in blue? Your task is honourable. What better vocation than to rid the country of evil? Thus, achieving this end can even justify the means!
The further into the forest, the more pervasive becomes this police culture. The heart of the beast is centered in elite CIB squads like Regional Crime, Criminal Intelligence and Drug Squad. These are the destinations to which the most ambitious and zealous aspire. Together with the Armed Offenders Squad and Team Policing units, these entities are the bastion of police culture.
Of course there are those who do not aspire to these objectives but then, the police is also a government department which always harbor a good number of 'glide timers': there to collect their pay and do as little as possible, which is the best route to longevity in any government agency. Often these people will suddenly find themselves floating on the top of the pool.
Every new entrant runs the same gauntlet. No recruit is ever formally 'taught' to use violence, to lie and cover up. None of my mentors did that to me and I never did it to those whom I mentored. But the culture sends a very clear message. 'When you witness transgression by a colleague, keep your mouth shut at worst and at best, provide an account which supports the miscreant and helps him/her out of a sticky situation.' If you don't, as a new recruit, you are ostracized. You may as well quit there and then. But once you have provided succor, you have taken your next step into the forest. Later you will witness another indiscretion and you will again 'cover'. After all, you have been accepted as one of the team. You are 'reliable'. To lose that status is not a desirable outcome. But already you are compromised. Then one day you will commit an indiscretion and others will cover for you. Then you are beholden. Then you have entered the forest proper. There is no light to show the way home.
When I speak about a police culture, I speak about the environment I have described. It is introverted, self protecting and lacking objectivity. It is a culture which looks after itself and has a certain view of how life should proceed. It is reinforced by drinking and bonding sessions. The 'them and us' ethos becomes tangible. What is more, the culture is working class conservative in its origins. Bigoted and intolerant. Few of its officer corps are university graduates and even fewer hail from private schools. There is no network which pervades the upper echelons of society. The police are insular.
If someone has tattoos or hair too long or dresses the 'wrong' way or does not have 'acceptable' politics, then they are one of 'them' and not to be trusted. Conversely liberals are a menace to stability and are even more dangerous than unemployed Maori.
I recall when as a detective in the mid seventies, I applied to go to university and was asked by my commissioned officer: "Meurant. Why do you want to go to university? Are you a communist?" The message was pretty clear. This was at the height of Vietnam. The police sub culture did not approve of its members being associated with undesirable elements who frequented establishments of enlightenment!
When I did finally go to university I found my lecturers to include Michael Basset, Phil Goff and Helen Clark, all of whom where later my peers in parliament but who at the time I entered university, shared decidedly different political beliefs to me. Yet even though I argued, as an example, that US foreign policy in Vietnam was 'defensive' (domino theory), these people approved my assignments. They were prepared to tolerate a philistine within their midst, suppress their natural aversion to me and mark my opinions objectively. This, as I reflect, juxtaposes starkly the attitude or culture of the two institutions. One institution is prepared to tolerate alternative views. The other is not.
I advanced in the rank structure relatively quickly in the police and soon found myself incarcerated as supervisor in a control room; a job I loathed. So I did go to university and here, the first signs of light began to reappear. Slowly the mist began to abate and I saw things from a different perspective. In all, I did eleven years at either Auckland or Victoria universities. I am immensely grateful for how those institutions unwittingly help me exorcise the demon of excessive exposure to police culture.
This 'culture' manifests in many different forms. Three recent examples will illustrate my point and demonstrate that it is as alive and well as it was in my day:
John Dewar. Recently incarcerated for, according to the view of the Court, covering up for the despicable conduct of assistant commissioner Rickards and two other police officers. John Dewar was one of the best sergeants I ever had as an inspector, but the 'culture' manifest in his destiny in a most tragic manner for him.
Then there was the police shooting of a man in Christchurch. The law is clear when a cop or civilian may kill another human being. One must fear on reasonable grounds, death or grievous injury to oneself or a third person which cannot otherwise be prevented. In my view the circumstances of the killing are not as transparent as the police public relations section would have us believe. A man shot wielding a hammer on cars! Not dissimilar to a man shot, wielding a golf club against shop windows.
The proper place to test the validity of police action is before a Court. The strength of our police is public confidence and support; without which they are nothing. The best way to retain that public support is for transparency and that is best achieved by testing police actions in a Court of law. Yet immediately after the killing we have the police association representative, completely out of line in my view, seeking to influence the outcome by claiming the shooting was justifiable and that we should trust the police to judge their own actions. This of course is the manifestation once again of the police culture: look after the police. That is quite different, in my view, to looking after the rule of law.
Finally there is the recent implementation of draconian anti terror legislation to combat routine crimes and offences in the community. Police say they have collated information over a period of 12 months which on analysis leads them to the conclusion that there is a real threat to the stability and security of our country. The problem as I see it is, that information they have has been self assessed by the same people who collate the data or at best, by the supervisor of the 'intelligence unit' and his superior; all of whom view society from within the forest and with vested interests in producing an outcome which justifies the retention of their unit. These subjective conclusions are presented to judicial officers as the basis of justification for warrants and implementation of anti terror legislation which abrogate the most basic of our legal rights.
No longer are we protected from arbitrary detention without being charged and the legal requirement to be taken before a Court as soon as possible. This I find unacceptable.
I am also disappointed that too many New Zealanders appear not to comprehend the significance of what it means to our legal structure when on the basis of subjective analysis by the police, these Guardians substantially usurp the role of the judiciary as a check and balance against tyrannical tendencies. There is a fundamental flaw in the present legislation where it allows a subjective test of police information by police, to form the basis of reason to catapult us onto a terror alert footing. It is even more disturbing to me when I know the environment where these decision are made, is deep in the forest. What the police are effectively saying is:
"In the Ureweras there are weapons of mass destruction. Trust us." Sound familiar?
I have been in the forest. In the seventies I was a detective on Regional Crime and Drug Squad. I was also on the AOS. My formal police assessments were high. 'Excellent' as a detective. 'Outstanding' as a commissioned officer. In my formative years my immediate supervisors included detective sergeant John Hughes, detective inspector Graham Perry and later detective inspector Bruce Hutton (Hutton was my boss on my first homicide: the Crewe murders). These men were legends in their own time, each of them relentless and with a determination of mind few could match. Together with half a dozen other young detectives, we formed a formidable unit; we became a legend in our own time.
Our adversaries were serious villains: Peter Fulcher, Mihaly Bede, Terry Clarke alias Mr Asia, the Saffiti boys and several gangs. This was a particularly violent time in the history of policing in New Zealand. We were right in the middle. It was inevitable that we, who consistently faced angry men in dark alleys, would have allegations made against us. I had my share against me.
There were allegations of excessive force; that I was aware of but did nothing about an offender alleged being dangled by his ankles from the fourth floor of the police station; perjury and even one of extracting a confession from a drug dealer by playing on him Russian Roulette with a police issue revolver. These allegations were of course outrageous untruths without foundation and never sustained.
In 1981 I was seconded to the police Red Escort Group - Red Squad. I later wrote a book about the exploits of the squad. That initiative catapulted me into the headlines for the first time. On the one hand, I believe it provided the impetus for me to gain selection for National as a Member of Parliament in a conservative seat. On other hand, because I later became a Member of Parliament and had written the book, The Red Squad Story, I became synonymous with Red Squad and alone have endure the odium and contempt heaped upon that police unit, as the tide of public opinion turned.
My last job in the police was inspector in charge of special operations and a criminal intelligence section. At the time the focus was on the activities of Maori activists at Carrington hospital. I took raw police data and used it in my Maiden Speech. At the time I believed in the conclusions we as a police unit had peer reviewed. Some form of revolution or armed insurrection had been threatened. There were threats of 'Kill white die a hero". Maori wanted political sovereignty. Maori activist Sid Jackson was one of several who had been to Libya. But did a contrary political view and aspirations really pose a threat to the security and stability of our country? History has provided the answer. There has been no revolution and at least one of the Maori activists of those times is now in Parliament working within the system.
I made a mistake when I took the raw police data and used in my Maiden Speech. It took another 9 years in parliament, another 3 years at university and as I do now, living in East Europe where the legal protections and freedoms we take for granted often do not exist, for me to finally step out of the forest and see it for what it is.
I urge every New Zealander not to allow the State apparatus to take from you by default, legal rights people long before us fought for, died for. I urge every New Zealand to contact their Member of Parliament and express concern that the anti terror legislation currently before parliament, be placed on 'hold' until the true nature of the present police raids under the auspicious of terror legislation, is tested before the Courts.
Is a delay of a few months too much to much to ask before we take the next step toward undermining the most significant legal document ever which has endured since 1215? The Magna Carta.
Like most recruits, I entered the police as an impressionable young man with a basic education, from a working class environment in provincial New Zealand. There were hundreds of peers like me, before me and after. I was nothing special but I was altruistic. We were all cannon fodder. Easy to manipulate. We looked at the forest before us in awe.
The moment you step into the police, this sub culture within NZ culture hits you. You are immediately part of the thin blue line. You are part of a team and that team looks after itself. You are special. You are the border between good and evil. The attitudes of the police instructors, armed not with teaching certificates but with ten years exposure to the police sub culture, either consciously or subconsciously invite you into the forest.
To step out of police college is to take the next step into the forest. You are now part of the difference between law and order in the streets where gangs would rule and evil would triumph. But for you and your fellow coppers, society would be a dangerous place. Your mission is to protect society from this evil. Very soon you learn to decide what is evil and what is not. You are no longer just a collector of human rubbish at the base of the cliff but you have an obligation; yes, even a duty to guide the country to a decent society. That direction is best decided by you and others in your sub culture of police, for what better epitomizes the values of a decent society than those cherished by the men and women in blue? Your task is honourable. What better vocation than to rid the country of evil? Thus, achieving this end can even justify the means!
The further into the forest, the more pervasive becomes this police culture. The heart of the beast is centered in elite CIB squads like Regional Crime, Criminal Intelligence and Drug Squad. These are the destinations to which the most ambitious and zealous aspire. Together with the Armed Offenders Squad and Team Policing units, these entities are the bastion of police culture.
Of course there are those who do not aspire to these objectives but then, the police is also a government department which always harbor a good number of 'glide timers': there to collect their pay and do as little as possible, which is the best route to longevity in any government agency. Often these people will suddenly find themselves floating on the top of the pool.
Every new entrant runs the same gauntlet. No recruit is ever formally 'taught' to use violence, to lie and cover up. None of my mentors did that to me and I never did it to those whom I mentored. But the culture sends a very clear message. 'When you witness transgression by a colleague, keep your mouth shut at worst and at best, provide an account which supports the miscreant and helps him/her out of a sticky situation.' If you don't, as a new recruit, you are ostracized. You may as well quit there and then. But once you have provided succor, you have taken your next step into the forest. Later you will witness another indiscretion and you will again 'cover'. After all, you have been accepted as one of the team. You are 'reliable'. To lose that status is not a desirable outcome. But already you are compromised. Then one day you will commit an indiscretion and others will cover for you. Then you are beholden. Then you have entered the forest proper. There is no light to show the way home.
When I speak about a police culture, I speak about the environment I have described. It is introverted, self protecting and lacking objectivity. It is a culture which looks after itself and has a certain view of how life should proceed. It is reinforced by drinking and bonding sessions. The 'them and us' ethos becomes tangible. What is more, the culture is working class conservative in its origins. Bigoted and intolerant. Few of its officer corps are university graduates and even fewer hail from private schools. There is no network which pervades the upper echelons of society. The police are insular.
If someone has tattoos or hair too long or dresses the 'wrong' way or does not have 'acceptable' politics, then they are one of 'them' and not to be trusted. Conversely liberals are a menace to stability and are even more dangerous than unemployed Maori.
I recall when as a detective in the mid seventies, I applied to go to university and was asked by my commissioned officer: "Meurant. Why do you want to go to university? Are you a communist?" The message was pretty clear. This was at the height of Vietnam. The police sub culture did not approve of its members being associated with undesirable elements who frequented establishments of enlightenment!
When I did finally go to university I found my lecturers to include Michael Basset, Phil Goff and Helen Clark, all of whom where later my peers in parliament but who at the time I entered university, shared decidedly different political beliefs to me. Yet even though I argued, as an example, that US foreign policy in Vietnam was 'defensive' (domino theory), these people approved my assignments. They were prepared to tolerate a philistine within their midst, suppress their natural aversion to me and mark my opinions objectively. This, as I reflect, juxtaposes starkly the attitude or culture of the two institutions. One institution is prepared to tolerate alternative views. The other is not.
I advanced in the rank structure relatively quickly in the police and soon found myself incarcerated as supervisor in a control room; a job I loathed. So I did go to university and here, the first signs of light began to reappear. Slowly the mist began to abate and I saw things from a different perspective. In all, I did eleven years at either Auckland or Victoria universities. I am immensely grateful for how those institutions unwittingly help me exorcise the demon of excessive exposure to police culture.
This 'culture' manifests in many different forms. Three recent examples will illustrate my point and demonstrate that it is as alive and well as it was in my day:
John Dewar. Recently incarcerated for, according to the view of the Court, covering up for the despicable conduct of assistant commissioner Rickards and two other police officers. John Dewar was one of the best sergeants I ever had as an inspector, but the 'culture' manifest in his destiny in a most tragic manner for him.
Then there was the police shooting of a man in Christchurch. The law is clear when a cop or civilian may kill another human being. One must fear on reasonable grounds, death or grievous injury to oneself or a third person which cannot otherwise be prevented. In my view the circumstances of the killing are not as transparent as the police public relations section would have us believe. A man shot wielding a hammer on cars! Not dissimilar to a man shot, wielding a golf club against shop windows.
The proper place to test the validity of police action is before a Court. The strength of our police is public confidence and support; without which they are nothing. The best way to retain that public support is for transparency and that is best achieved by testing police actions in a Court of law. Yet immediately after the killing we have the police association representative, completely out of line in my view, seeking to influence the outcome by claiming the shooting was justifiable and that we should trust the police to judge their own actions. This of course is the manifestation once again of the police culture: look after the police. That is quite different, in my view, to looking after the rule of law.
Finally there is the recent implementation of draconian anti terror legislation to combat routine crimes and offences in the community. Police say they have collated information over a period of 12 months which on analysis leads them to the conclusion that there is a real threat to the stability and security of our country. The problem as I see it is, that information they have has been self assessed by the same people who collate the data or at best, by the supervisor of the 'intelligence unit' and his superior; all of whom view society from within the forest and with vested interests in producing an outcome which justifies the retention of their unit. These subjective conclusions are presented to judicial officers as the basis of justification for warrants and implementation of anti terror legislation which abrogate the most basic of our legal rights.
No longer are we protected from arbitrary detention without being charged and the legal requirement to be taken before a Court as soon as possible. This I find unacceptable.
I am also disappointed that too many New Zealanders appear not to comprehend the significance of what it means to our legal structure when on the basis of subjective analysis by the police, these Guardians substantially usurp the role of the judiciary as a check and balance against tyrannical tendencies. There is a fundamental flaw in the present legislation where it allows a subjective test of police information by police, to form the basis of reason to catapult us onto a terror alert footing. It is even more disturbing to me when I know the environment where these decision are made, is deep in the forest. What the police are effectively saying is:
"In the Ureweras there are weapons of mass destruction. Trust us." Sound familiar?
I have been in the forest. In the seventies I was a detective on Regional Crime and Drug Squad. I was also on the AOS. My formal police assessments were high. 'Excellent' as a detective. 'Outstanding' as a commissioned officer. In my formative years my immediate supervisors included detective sergeant John Hughes, detective inspector Graham Perry and later detective inspector Bruce Hutton (Hutton was my boss on my first homicide: the Crewe murders). These men were legends in their own time, each of them relentless and with a determination of mind few could match. Together with half a dozen other young detectives, we formed a formidable unit; we became a legend in our own time.
Our adversaries were serious villains: Peter Fulcher, Mihaly Bede, Terry Clarke alias Mr Asia, the Saffiti boys and several gangs. This was a particularly violent time in the history of policing in New Zealand. We were right in the middle. It was inevitable that we, who consistently faced angry men in dark alleys, would have allegations made against us. I had my share against me.
There were allegations of excessive force; that I was aware of but did nothing about an offender alleged being dangled by his ankles from the fourth floor of the police station; perjury and even one of extracting a confession from a drug dealer by playing on him Russian Roulette with a police issue revolver. These allegations were of course outrageous untruths without foundation and never sustained.
In 1981 I was seconded to the police Red Escort Group - Red Squad. I later wrote a book about the exploits of the squad. That initiative catapulted me into the headlines for the first time. On the one hand, I believe it provided the impetus for me to gain selection for National as a Member of Parliament in a conservative seat. On other hand, because I later became a Member of Parliament and had written the book, The Red Squad Story, I became synonymous with Red Squad and alone have endure the odium and contempt heaped upon that police unit, as the tide of public opinion turned.
My last job in the police was inspector in charge of special operations and a criminal intelligence section. At the time the focus was on the activities of Maori activists at Carrington hospital. I took raw police data and used it in my Maiden Speech. At the time I believed in the conclusions we as a police unit had peer reviewed. Some form of revolution or armed insurrection had been threatened. There were threats of 'Kill white die a hero". Maori wanted political sovereignty. Maori activist Sid Jackson was one of several who had been to Libya. But did a contrary political view and aspirations really pose a threat to the security and stability of our country? History has provided the answer. There has been no revolution and at least one of the Maori activists of those times is now in Parliament working within the system.
I made a mistake when I took the raw police data and used in my Maiden Speech. It took another 9 years in parliament, another 3 years at university and as I do now, living in East Europe where the legal protections and freedoms we take for granted often do not exist, for me to finally step out of the forest and see it for what it is.
I urge every New Zealander not to allow the State apparatus to take from you by default, legal rights people long before us fought for, died for. I urge every New Zealand to contact their Member of Parliament and express concern that the anti terror legislation currently before parliament, be placed on 'hold' until the true nature of the present police raids under the auspicious of terror legislation, is tested before the Courts.
Is a delay of a few months too much to much to ask before we take the next step toward undermining the most significant legal document ever which has endured since 1215? The Magna Carta.
Labels:
police,
Ross Meurant
Monday, July 26, 2010
It's a Wild World in the Wairarapa, More Threats:
About an hour ago, at 2 pm 27th July 2010, I was trying to prepare for Court with the pathetic amount of information available, and notably without the audio recording of the call to emergency services from witnesses to the attack on 11th February 2009, of Michael Murphy screaming threats at me as he tried to smash my door in and attack me, which the police are corruptly refusing to provide after claiming that the Privacy Act says I cant have any information created by other people. Lies, of course, it says no such thing, the NZ Police make it up as they go along. Twelve people stand between me and seven years in prison tomorrow, because of these corruptly laid charges.
Anyway, there I was, minding my own business as usual, when Hayden, mentioned in the previous post in regard to the way that he and his cousin Tracy are not charged for other violent and threatening criminal behaviour, and stealing $500 respectively, because of his mother's relationship with Constable Steve Wakefield, who although retired now, is still kept in the manner in which he has become accustomed by profiting from the odd "perk job", like driving the police van that took me over the Remutakas on the 22nd 23rd February after his mates arrested me on the illegal warrant obtained in the Masterton Court on 16th February 2010 on the basis of information that the Registrar and the Police knew was false.
Whoops, there I go again, anyway Hayden arrived, in his silver ute, with a woman with curly red hair called Kim who fancies herself as being a bit of a know all on horses and gets around in a stetson most of the time, turned up here shouting threats and giving the fingers and carrying on. That was the sole purpose of the visit. Hayden got out of the ute and shouted "I don't care what you write on the internet, you can write what you like. You'll be sorry."
So in honour of that, and as evidence of how this is typical of the corrupt way police deal with violence in the Wairarapa, here's a copy of a statement by a woman who was visiting me with her two young children when he came around on another occasion, only a week or two after police - including Constable Laura Rhymer, the officer in charge of the case being heard tomorrow, served him with a trespass notice - or told me they had. This witness was present when Hayden arrived, with his parents, ranted and raved, making all sorts of threats, then smashed a bedroom window while we and the terrified children looked in amazement as the police who were present - I had called them - did absolutely nothing about it!
Will be putting the recording of the threatening phone messages from Hayden on the site soon, in the mean time, leave the horses and the vehicles alone Hayden, I PAID for the car you've threatened to "deal to" - remember?
These two layabouts should get a job instead of carrying on like this! I am tempted to write about what Hayden told me they do all day and night, but good taste prevents me from delving into that depravity, they say that the devil finds work for idle hands, these people have too much time on their hands and too much taxpayers money to squander, running around all day, drinking all night, these people have no intention of ever getting a job, that's the last thing they want, they'd rather bludge off the taxpayers as if the world owes them a living.
The phone message is interesting in that it says he's moving into my rented house because it belongs to him, a tale he told the police when they served the trespass notice, but not WINZ apparently. He didn't tell them about any of his considerable assets apparently. The message and the documents above also confirm the use of the exact same language the police have charged me with using but refused to charge anyone else with! More blatant corruption - one law for some people another law for others.
Thousands of dollars in tickets for bike helmet fines and Constable Wakefield drives me all the way over the Remutaka's and Haywards Hill and back, slipping and sliding around in a stainless steel box with sharp edges - and where's my safety gear for that? I had far more need of a helmet then than any time I'm riding my bike - let's get real! And how much did that little illegal warrant excercise cost the tax payers all up to line Steve Wakefield's pocket. There wasn't even a seat belt!
Hayden boasts about sticking pornographic pictures on the Catholic Church and other rubbish, he should grow up and get a job, delivering pamphlets like me, there's nothing stopping him, apart from his belief, encouraged by his mother, that the world owes him a living because his mother's having an affair with the local cop. Don't come round here threatening me. If anything happens to my property or the Community Garden horses, everyone will ll know who threatened to do it.
Here's another statement about how the police carry on:
And another:

This is a letter from the parents of children at the South End School about the letter sacking me regarding the false allegation of child abuse charges.
This is one of the letters that the School denied receiving, and lied to the Privacy Commissioner about, and why the Principal didn't turn up for Court the other day, because he is a LIAR, who told the children at the South End School that I didn't turn up to Court. Well children, and parents, I certainly did turn up to Court, Mr O'Leary was the one who didn't turn up because he's telling lies and would have been forced to admit it.
When is the Board of Trustees going to meet with me, apologise to me, and admit that Rod O'Leary and Gavin Kennedy are liars.The corrupt police lied to them about having charged me - like they've been lying for years about charging me with child abuse - I am not a child abuser, I do not pervert the course of justice, I am not a criminal.
Kennedy signed the letter on the basis of lies spread by the police and he knows it, it has been confirmed now that he's been forced to admit the existence of the notes made by the staff representative on the Board of Trustees, they are still lying in the face of the evidence - who wants liars teaching their children? REPEAT liars - O'Leary has lied and lied and LIED about these matters!
By the way, take a look at the state of the gardens outside the school - what an utter disgrace! "Whaea Michelle" was in a big hurry to rip out our parsley and kale and everythign else that we planted, and throw it away, while screaming "F*** off, f***" off at me - shame that was the entire extent of her "efforts". Friends of the Gardens used to maintain those beds beautifully with the children until Whaea Michelle destroyed them over a year ago, they haven't been touched since - except the bit of overpriced "potted colour" they planted and then never watered.
Anyway, there I was, minding my own business as usual, when Hayden, mentioned in the previous post in regard to the way that he and his cousin Tracy are not charged for other violent and threatening criminal behaviour, and stealing $500 respectively, because of his mother's relationship with Constable Steve Wakefield, who although retired now, is still kept in the manner in which he has become accustomed by profiting from the odd "perk job", like driving the police van that took me over the Remutakas on the 22nd 23rd February after his mates arrested me on the illegal warrant obtained in the Masterton Court on 16th February 2010 on the basis of information that the Registrar and the Police knew was false.
Whoops, there I go again, anyway Hayden arrived, in his silver ute, with a woman with curly red hair called Kim who fancies herself as being a bit of a know all on horses and gets around in a stetson most of the time, turned up here shouting threats and giving the fingers and carrying on. That was the sole purpose of the visit. Hayden got out of the ute and shouted "I don't care what you write on the internet, you can write what you like. You'll be sorry."
So in honour of that, and as evidence of how this is typical of the corrupt way police deal with violence in the Wairarapa, here's a copy of a statement by a woman who was visiting me with her two young children when he came around on another occasion, only a week or two after police - including Constable Laura Rhymer, the officer in charge of the case being heard tomorrow, served him with a trespass notice - or told me they had. This witness was present when Hayden arrived, with his parents, ranted and raved, making all sorts of threats, then smashed a bedroom window while we and the terrified children looked in amazement as the police who were present - I had called them - did absolutely nothing about it!
Will be putting the recording of the threatening phone messages from Hayden on the site soon, in the mean time, leave the horses and the vehicles alone Hayden, I PAID for the car you've threatened to "deal to" - remember?
These two layabouts should get a job instead of carrying on like this! I am tempted to write about what Hayden told me they do all day and night, but good taste prevents me from delving into that depravity, they say that the devil finds work for idle hands, these people have too much time on their hands and too much taxpayers money to squander, running around all day, drinking all night, these people have no intention of ever getting a job, that's the last thing they want, they'd rather bludge off the taxpayers as if the world owes them a living.
The phone message is interesting in that it says he's moving into my rented house because it belongs to him, a tale he told the police when they served the trespass notice, but not WINZ apparently. He didn't tell them about any of his considerable assets apparently. The message and the documents above also confirm the use of the exact same language the police have charged me with using but refused to charge anyone else with! More blatant corruption - one law for some people another law for others.
Thousands of dollars in tickets for bike helmet fines and Constable Wakefield drives me all the way over the Remutaka's and Haywards Hill and back, slipping and sliding around in a stainless steel box with sharp edges - and where's my safety gear for that? I had far more need of a helmet then than any time I'm riding my bike - let's get real! And how much did that little illegal warrant excercise cost the tax payers all up to line Steve Wakefield's pocket. There wasn't even a seat belt!
Hayden boasts about sticking pornographic pictures on the Catholic Church and other rubbish, he should grow up and get a job, delivering pamphlets like me, there's nothing stopping him, apart from his belief, encouraged by his mother, that the world owes him a living because his mother's having an affair with the local cop. Don't come round here threatening me. If anything happens to my property or the Community Garden horses, everyone will ll know who threatened to do it.
Here's another statement about how the police carry on:
And another:

This is a letter from the parents of children at the South End School about the letter sacking me regarding the false allegation of child abuse charges.
This is one of the letters that the School denied receiving, and lied to the Privacy Commissioner about, and why the Principal didn't turn up for Court the other day, because he is a LIAR, who told the children at the South End School that I didn't turn up to Court. Well children, and parents, I certainly did turn up to Court, Mr O'Leary was the one who didn't turn up because he's telling lies and would have been forced to admit it.
When is the Board of Trustees going to meet with me, apologise to me, and admit that Rod O'Leary and Gavin Kennedy are liars.The corrupt police lied to them about having charged me - like they've been lying for years about charging me with child abuse - I am not a child abuser, I do not pervert the course of justice, I am not a criminal.
Kennedy signed the letter on the basis of lies spread by the police and he knows it, it has been confirmed now that he's been forced to admit the existence of the notes made by the staff representative on the Board of Trustees, they are still lying in the face of the evidence - who wants liars teaching their children? REPEAT liars - O'Leary has lied and lied and LIED about these matters!
By the way, take a look at the state of the gardens outside the school - what an utter disgrace! "Whaea Michelle" was in a big hurry to rip out our parsley and kale and everythign else that we planted, and throw it away, while screaming "F*** off, f***" off at me - shame that was the entire extent of her "efforts". Friends of the Gardens used to maintain those beds beautifully with the children until Whaea Michelle destroyed them over a year ago, they haven't been touched since - except the bit of overpriced "potted colour" they planted and then never watered.
Friday, July 23, 2010
Corrupt Constable Wakefield's Malicious Vendetta:
Yet again the corrupt, bullying local police have proved me right. "Whose behaviour does your child reflect?" ask the little posters with the mirrors in that are on the walls of all the police stations in New Zealand.
A couple of hours ago, Constable Mike Wakefield demonstrated why his father retired having never made it higher than the rank of Constable, and why Mike probably won't either. Because they are both corrupt, nasty, bullies.
Riding along, minding my own business as usual, not bothering anybody, as usual, quarter to eleven at night, cold, wet, homeless - as a direct result of the police telling everyone I'm a child abuser.
Gutless wonder Mike Wakefield wasted more taxpayers money and police resources by using his discretion to maliciously stop me and detain me for a considerable time and finally issuing me with a ticket for not wearing a helmet and "no light on bike" - well there was a light on the bike, and when he asked me if there was any reason I wan't wearing a helmet I replied politely that there was (as he is well aware because he's seen it many times), in the form of a letter from my doctor confirming that I should be exempted on medical grounds. As can be seen in the picture above (despite the letter) I often wear a helmet, and usually wear a reflective, high visibility vest. He asked me if I had the letter with me, I produced it. Instead of just getting on with his job, now that he and his lying mates have cost me my job, the w***er made me stand there, wet and cold, for ages and ages while he had a good laugh, sitting there in his car, looking things up, writing things down, trying his very best to take as long as possible and taking every opportunity to humiliate and degrade and threaten and abuse me, but only succeeding in humiliating and degrading himself and the New Zealand Police with his petty malicious vendetta, if only he had the wits to see it.
And here's local village idiot Gary McPhee, dressed from head to foot in his no visibility, vanity driven, black leather fashion statement, bleating about his ACC fees - what an utter hypocrite!
The ACC has been his main source of income for years! When he hasn't been getting it himself for all the ridiculous "accidents" he causes or is involved in, he's been busy filling up his pockets by claiming he's been the "caregiver" of his son Jesse for years, after he talked Jesse into getting a great big motorbike when he was 19 or something, and of course, Jesse ran it straight into the side of a bus and got serious head injuries.
I've ridden my bicycle for many, many years, for hundreds of miles, and I've never claimed ACC as a result of a bicycle accident, except when I got 15 stitches in my knee after the damn helmet slipped and caused me to fall off a couple of years ago, and the hospital filled in the form automatically.
The thing is this, and it's very simple: High visibility vests prevent accidents, cycle helmets are no use whatsoever until after you've had an accident. Take a good look at this idiot in his silly get up, he flipped his silly motorbike, sidecar and all, in a spectacularly stupid crash recently after the "counterweight" he uses for carting coffins around on his stupid Harley Davidson (I know!) shifted and slipped and dug into the road cartwheeling the entire horrendous contraption arse over kite in the middle of the road recently. He's a total and utter idiot of the highest order, and the day he and his bikie mates wear high vis vests I'll wear a bike helmet.
And what about those policemen who got shot with an air rifle and killed because they weren't wearing their protective vests? I've had enough of this one law for some people and another law for others.
Here's me on my little bike, my brother gave it to me, and I go everywhere on it. If I'm not wearing a high vis vest I'm wearing a red t shirt. And a good hat. Looks like I'm showing someone how long McPhee's attention span is or something.
The fact is, that I manage to keep safe and McPhee doesn't. He has "accident" after "accident", and his mates, the corrupt local cops, just keep letting him off over and over again.
Like they let McPhee off after he committed a nasty, drunken home invasion and assault on the innocent occupants of a local flat and then had the cheek to boast about it in the 'news'paper - an outrageously blatant act of corruption!
Mike Wakefield is harassing and bullying me for what I have written about his father, corrupt, sleazy, Constable Steve Wakefield, who is well known in Carterton for his corruption and his affairs with local woman, notably one called Jenny, whose daughter is married to another police officer, and who lied to the Tenancy Tribunal about the door which was damaged in the attack on me on 11th February 2009, and also Jo Roffe, who was sucking money out of the Carterton Community Centre which is why Wakefield turned a blind eye to the fraud there, and why he and his mates continue to ignore it despite letters from several lawyers. Constable Steve Wakefield was the officer in charge of the corrupt non-investigation of the allegations regarding the Carterton Community Centre, he covered up the bullying and fraud, the Carterton Community Centre was nothing but a little slush fund for Wakefield's other little friends who were stealing money hand over fist from the Centre and all the different bank accounts it controlled! While he was having it off with Jo Roffe, who was sucking up over $600 a week of taxpayer's money for her pathetic little craft courses, and Georgina Beyer, sucking up vast amounts of taxpayer's money to teach the young people of the Wairarapa "Life Skills" because the community leaders, like the local police, Councillors, WINZ managers, etc, who are all being paid taxpayer's money to make good decisions for our community, all thought it was a great idea to pay a transvestite prostitute a fortune to teach our kids "her" extremely dubious "Life Skills" - when are the people of the Wairarapa going to wake up, grow a brain and start using it?
Wakefield was/is also having it off with Jenny's niece Tracy,which is why she got away with stealing $500 from a local woman, after lying about having received a phone call from me and Jenny's son which created an opportunity for her to steal the money. Wakefield and his corrupt police made sure Tracy got away with telling the lie. So far. We are not putting up with this and will seek justice no matter how long it takes, because this is blatant and extreme corruption. Jenny's son came to my home repeatedly, threatening me and carrying on, police were called after he caused a dangerous incident involving a child, and told me they'd given him a trespass notice as requested. A couple of weeks later police stood and watched as Jenny's son shouted threats and smashed windows at my home while I, and a woman who was visiting me, and her two young children, were there. Police refused to intervene, or to charge Jenny's son with any offence whatsoever! Just like they refused to charge McPhee for the drunken home invasion and assault, and just like they refuse to charge Michael Murphy and his mates with the attack on me, which funnily enough, involves drunken lout McPhee again: The Mayoral Diary for February 2009 and the letter from the Board of Trustees of the South End School makes it clear that McPhee and his mates the corrupt police and Michael Murphy planned the attack on me on 11th February, and that they had been coming to my home and threatening and intimidating me on a regular basis, and that the Police lied to the school deliberately in order to get me sacked, just like they lie to anyone who offers me accommodation, or grazing for the community garden horses. Police and Michael Murphy lied about an alleged incident in the supermarket and tried to use the lie to justify the violent attack on me instead of charging the violent offenders!
Constable Steve Wakefield was famous round here for his corruption, and the sleazy manner in which he habitually offered to let women off - and I use the term 'women' loosely - VERY loosely - in exchange for "favours" - the sleazier the better. Everyone knows it - there were many MANY complaints to the PCA about Stephen Wakefield and his sleazy, predatory, corrupt behaviour!.
Constable Mike Wakefield is a corrupt, nasty creep who likes to pick on little people, like me, because he's a gutless wonder and a corrupt bully, like his father. He's got his snout deep in the trough, sucking up our money. Wairarapa police are universally despised and their disgraceful record is well documented. They pick on poor depressed, homeless mental health patients and arrogantly boast of the way they destroy lives with nasty lies and gossip while they corruptly cover up a blatant and extremely violent home invasion and attack on innocent people.
Then there's the other local cop's son, who took a whole lot of methamphetamine - as he regularly did - and then viciously tortured, bashed and murdered another tiny, totally harmless person, breached bail and pervertedd the course of justice and contacted Crown witnesses etc, who got off with a 3 year non-parole period and manslaughter, after his other two mates got considerably longer sentences for MURDER - after the cops son actually confessed to murder in a text message to the very Crown witness he interfered with!
Corruption is out of control in the Wairarapa. Here's statements of witnesses to more outrageous tax payer funded bullying:

A couple of hours ago, Constable Mike Wakefield demonstrated why his father retired having never made it higher than the rank of Constable, and why Mike probably won't either. Because they are both corrupt, nasty, bullies.
Riding along, minding my own business as usual, not bothering anybody, as usual, quarter to eleven at night, cold, wet, homeless - as a direct result of the police telling everyone I'm a child abuser.
Gutless wonder Mike Wakefield wasted more taxpayers money and police resources by using his discretion to maliciously stop me and detain me for a considerable time and finally issuing me with a ticket for not wearing a helmet and "no light on bike" - well there was a light on the bike, and when he asked me if there was any reason I wan't wearing a helmet I replied politely that there was (as he is well aware because he's seen it many times), in the form of a letter from my doctor confirming that I should be exempted on medical grounds. As can be seen in the picture above (despite the letter) I often wear a helmet, and usually wear a reflective, high visibility vest. He asked me if I had the letter with me, I produced it. Instead of just getting on with his job, now that he and his lying mates have cost me my job, the w***er made me stand there, wet and cold, for ages and ages while he had a good laugh, sitting there in his car, looking things up, writing things down, trying his very best to take as long as possible and taking every opportunity to humiliate and degrade and threaten and abuse me, but only succeeding in humiliating and degrading himself and the New Zealand Police with his petty malicious vendetta, if only he had the wits to see it.
And here's local village idiot Gary McPhee, dressed from head to foot in his no visibility, vanity driven, black leather fashion statement, bleating about his ACC fees - what an utter hypocrite!
The ACC has been his main source of income for years! When he hasn't been getting it himself for all the ridiculous "accidents" he causes or is involved in, he's been busy filling up his pockets by claiming he's been the "caregiver" of his son Jesse for years, after he talked Jesse into getting a great big motorbike when he was 19 or something, and of course, Jesse ran it straight into the side of a bus and got serious head injuries.
I've ridden my bicycle for many, many years, for hundreds of miles, and I've never claimed ACC as a result of a bicycle accident, except when I got 15 stitches in my knee after the damn helmet slipped and caused me to fall off a couple of years ago, and the hospital filled in the form automatically.
The thing is this, and it's very simple: High visibility vests prevent accidents, cycle helmets are no use whatsoever until after you've had an accident. Take a good look at this idiot in his silly get up, he flipped his silly motorbike, sidecar and all, in a spectacularly stupid crash recently after the "counterweight" he uses for carting coffins around on his stupid Harley Davidson (I know!) shifted and slipped and dug into the road cartwheeling the entire horrendous contraption arse over kite in the middle of the road recently. He's a total and utter idiot of the highest order, and the day he and his bikie mates wear high vis vests I'll wear a bike helmet.
And what about those policemen who got shot with an air rifle and killed because they weren't wearing their protective vests? I've had enough of this one law for some people and another law for others.
Here's me on my little bike, my brother gave it to me, and I go everywhere on it. If I'm not wearing a high vis vest I'm wearing a red t shirt. And a good hat. Looks like I'm showing someone how long McPhee's attention span is or something.
The fact is, that I manage to keep safe and McPhee doesn't. He has "accident" after "accident", and his mates, the corrupt local cops, just keep letting him off over and over again.
Like they let McPhee off after he committed a nasty, drunken home invasion and assault on the innocent occupants of a local flat and then had the cheek to boast about it in the 'news'paper - an outrageously blatant act of corruption!
Mike Wakefield is harassing and bullying me for what I have written about his father, corrupt, sleazy, Constable Steve Wakefield, who is well known in Carterton for his corruption and his affairs with local woman, notably one called Jenny, whose daughter is married to another police officer, and who lied to the Tenancy Tribunal about the door which was damaged in the attack on me on 11th February 2009, and also Jo Roffe, who was sucking money out of the Carterton Community Centre which is why Wakefield turned a blind eye to the fraud there, and why he and his mates continue to ignore it despite letters from several lawyers. Constable Steve Wakefield was the officer in charge of the corrupt non-investigation of the allegations regarding the Carterton Community Centre, he covered up the bullying and fraud, the Carterton Community Centre was nothing but a little slush fund for Wakefield's other little friends who were stealing money hand over fist from the Centre and all the different bank accounts it controlled! While he was having it off with Jo Roffe, who was sucking up over $600 a week of taxpayer's money for her pathetic little craft courses, and Georgina Beyer, sucking up vast amounts of taxpayer's money to teach the young people of the Wairarapa "Life Skills" because the community leaders, like the local police, Councillors, WINZ managers, etc, who are all being paid taxpayer's money to make good decisions for our community, all thought it was a great idea to pay a transvestite prostitute a fortune to teach our kids "her" extremely dubious "Life Skills" - when are the people of the Wairarapa going to wake up, grow a brain and start using it?
Wakefield was/is also having it off with Jenny's niece Tracy,which is why she got away with stealing $500 from a local woman, after lying about having received a phone call from me and Jenny's son which created an opportunity for her to steal the money. Wakefield and his corrupt police made sure Tracy got away with telling the lie. So far. We are not putting up with this and will seek justice no matter how long it takes, because this is blatant and extreme corruption. Jenny's son came to my home repeatedly, threatening me and carrying on, police were called after he caused a dangerous incident involving a child, and told me they'd given him a trespass notice as requested. A couple of weeks later police stood and watched as Jenny's son shouted threats and smashed windows at my home while I, and a woman who was visiting me, and her two young children, were there. Police refused to intervene, or to charge Jenny's son with any offence whatsoever! Just like they refused to charge McPhee for the drunken home invasion and assault, and just like they refuse to charge Michael Murphy and his mates with the attack on me, which funnily enough, involves drunken lout McPhee again: The Mayoral Diary for February 2009 and the letter from the Board of Trustees of the South End School makes it clear that McPhee and his mates the corrupt police and Michael Murphy planned the attack on me on 11th February, and that they had been coming to my home and threatening and intimidating me on a regular basis, and that the Police lied to the school deliberately in order to get me sacked, just like they lie to anyone who offers me accommodation, or grazing for the community garden horses. Police and Michael Murphy lied about an alleged incident in the supermarket and tried to use the lie to justify the violent attack on me instead of charging the violent offenders!
Constable Steve Wakefield was famous round here for his corruption, and the sleazy manner in which he habitually offered to let women off - and I use the term 'women' loosely - VERY loosely - in exchange for "favours" - the sleazier the better. Everyone knows it - there were many MANY complaints to the PCA about Stephen Wakefield and his sleazy, predatory, corrupt behaviour!.
Constable Mike Wakefield is a corrupt, nasty creep who likes to pick on little people, like me, because he's a gutless wonder and a corrupt bully, like his father. He's got his snout deep in the trough, sucking up our money. Wairarapa police are universally despised and their disgraceful record is well documented. They pick on poor depressed, homeless mental health patients and arrogantly boast of the way they destroy lives with nasty lies and gossip while they corruptly cover up a blatant and extremely violent home invasion and attack on innocent people.
Then there's the other local cop's son, who took a whole lot of methamphetamine - as he regularly did - and then viciously tortured, bashed and murdered another tiny, totally harmless person, breached bail and pervertedd the course of justice and contacted Crown witnesses etc, who got off with a 3 year non-parole period and manslaughter, after his other two mates got considerably longer sentences for MURDER - after the cops son actually confessed to murder in a text message to the very Crown witness he interfered with!
Corruption is out of control in the Wairarapa. Here's statements of witnesses to more outrageous tax payer funded bullying:

Friday, July 16, 2010
Grand Bicycle Theft Inspires Another Home Invasion by Wairarapa Cops:
On Sunday afternoon, 4th July 2010, I was minding my own business, riding along on a bicycle, enjoying the sunshine, when Constable Harvey Pope, who has nearly made it to retirement and still never reached above the rank of Constable (like Steve Wakefield and Peter Cunningham) demonstrated (again) why that is.
Pulling up alongside me in his big flash police car, with all the bells and whistles, and flashing lights, he ordered me to stop. Of course I did, whereupon he got out of the car and set upon me. "That bike's stolen" he said.
"No it's not" I said, "yes it is" said Harvey. This went on for a while, before Harvey physically pushed me off the bike and seized it, saying he was taking it whether I liked it or not, and if I had a problem with that they would arrest me. I then said that I wanted my property such as the two bags attached to the bike, and their contents, etc. Pope said yes at first, then changed his mind and said no, he was seizing all my property as well as the bike, which was NOT even stolen in the first place.
I was extremely upset, Pope was loudly accusing me of being a thief, which I am not! I walked the short distance around the corner to my friends' house, leaving the bike with Pope, because I was concerned for my physical safety due to the menacing attitude of Pope and Dallinger - confirmed by a statement from a witness (link below). Shortly afterward we heard Pope and the other police officer, Dallinger, enter the house demanding to know where I was. My friend and I both felt afraid and intimidated by their shouting.
They then smashed in the door of the room I was in and attacked me, manhandling me out, handcuffing me, and assaulting me, bashing my head into the door frame, etc. They then wasted all afternoon taking me back to Masterton Police station and locking me up for hours before charging me with - wait for it - allegedly swearing at them. Not bike theft of course, because the bike wasn't stolen, like I told them.
Which is why they left it at the house where they smashed the door, and why I am still riding round on it, I rode it to Court. If they didn't falsely accuse people of being thieves when they aren't, maybe people wouldn't allegedly swear at them. This is just more malicious and vexatious litigation, more of Pope and Cunningham's vindictive witch hunt. More importantly, it's a total and utter waste of public resources and a criminal abuse of power - as well as a blatant attempt to pervert the course of justice.
Even if the bike HAD been stolen - that's NO excuse to smash in a door and assault anyone. No wonder local police are so despised. Here's a link to a statement made by a witness regarding a similar incident. The original is signed, I've removed the identifying details to protect the privacy of the witness.
Pope and Dallinger took delight in going on about the fact that Dallinger was from Dannevirke, and the corrupt cover up of an assault on me in about 2008 in Dannevirke which I believe Dallinger was involved in, then I had to listen to a tirade from Pope about how I had allegedly ruined the lives of everyone in Carterton, so I asked him to name just one of these people, and was amazed when he came out with the name Julie Hallam, the Deputy Electoral Officer who falsely claimed I had failed to submit an expenses return after the local body elections is 2007, described in more detail at this link to 'Election by Deception, How McPhee rigged the election', the architect of her own destiny as far as the article goes, which is what Pope was referring to.
Police took no further interest in the bicycle, because it wasn't stolen, as they knew in the first place, but charged me with swearing at them, then the police prosecutor conspired with the Court to convict me of it in my absence - I hadn't even entered a plea or had proper disclosure of information.
Police continue to ignore all my complaints, telling me to come into the station "for a chat about your complaints" - what a joke!!! Evidence shows that I've been into the local police stations numerous times and been laughed at, assaulted, abused, and told to "Piss off" by corrupt local officers on every single occasion I've tried to make a complaint! .
Have a look - and a listen - to how corrupt Constables Harvey Pope and Paul Dallinger lept into action when Tim Reynolds rang up (- emergency services apparently -) and made a deliberately false accusation against me for allegedly "taking" a bicycle - it wasn't his bicycle at all and he needs to be charged with making a false complaint to police - the point is that there are two different sets of rules here - the evidence of Dallinger and Popes corrupt sadism will be added to this post very soon, including full details of how they smashed in the bedroom door to "arrest" me as a result of the phone call in the clip below, and used the phone call as an excuse to detain me at the Masterton police station all afternoon and assault and abuse me. Here's the recording of Reynolds's pathetic complaint. He is a bully and a thief. - The woman pictured in the clip below is Kirsten Grenfell of Barnardos - a trouble making, bludger, who contacted Reynolds to complain that she's got a "smack in the gob" from another woman for having it off with her partner - Grenfell richly deserved it - she is a manipulative, spiteful trouble maker who regularly sleeps with other women's partners! Grenfell urged Reynolds to evict me so that she could come round and have it off with him when her partner was working without me to witness her nauseating, adulterous behaviour.
It can be seen from these documents that there was at least one witness to this incident (I have obscured her name to protect her privacy) - Dallinger and Pope tried to convince her to back up their story but the witness refused to do so because she was shocked at their actions, like the witness who wrote the statement at this link.
Now, here is the second page of the records of the police communications centre regarding this incident, which shows evidence of the three calls the police call taker apparently made to Reynolds to try and talk him into making a formal complaint - Reynolds repeatedly said he didn't want to or intend to do so! Dallinger and Pope knew perfectly well that no crime had been committed! THIS is what sadistic, vindictive local officers are doing while they're deliberately covering up for child abusers and paedophiles and making sure that our region regularly has TWICE the national rate of suicide - in a country with some of the highest rates in the world - REGULARLY!
Here's what Reynolds and his mates Wayne Friend, etc, have done to my television and the keyboard I used to teach children music with - Reynolds has illegally disposed of much of my other property as well, including two guitars, and police refuse to even acknowledge any of my complaints. I've been into the Carterton, Greytown and Masterton police stations REGULARLY to report this and other vandalism and theft of my property - not to mention the assaults from Reynolds and his mates! I get told to piss off every single time!
Pulling up alongside me in his big flash police car, with all the bells and whistles, and flashing lights, he ordered me to stop. Of course I did, whereupon he got out of the car and set upon me. "That bike's stolen" he said.
"No it's not" I said, "yes it is" said Harvey. This went on for a while, before Harvey physically pushed me off the bike and seized it, saying he was taking it whether I liked it or not, and if I had a problem with that they would arrest me. I then said that I wanted my property such as the two bags attached to the bike, and their contents, etc. Pope said yes at first, then changed his mind and said no, he was seizing all my property as well as the bike, which was NOT even stolen in the first place.
I was extremely upset, Pope was loudly accusing me of being a thief, which I am not! I walked the short distance around the corner to my friends' house, leaving the bike with Pope, because I was concerned for my physical safety due to the menacing attitude of Pope and Dallinger - confirmed by a statement from a witness (link below). Shortly afterward we heard Pope and the other police officer, Dallinger, enter the house demanding to know where I was. My friend and I both felt afraid and intimidated by their shouting.
They then smashed in the door of the room I was in and attacked me, manhandling me out, handcuffing me, and assaulting me, bashing my head into the door frame, etc. They then wasted all afternoon taking me back to Masterton Police station and locking me up for hours before charging me with - wait for it - allegedly swearing at them. Not bike theft of course, because the bike wasn't stolen, like I told them.
Which is why they left it at the house where they smashed the door, and why I am still riding round on it, I rode it to Court. If they didn't falsely accuse people of being thieves when they aren't, maybe people wouldn't allegedly swear at them. This is just more malicious and vexatious litigation, more of Pope and Cunningham's vindictive witch hunt. More importantly, it's a total and utter waste of public resources and a criminal abuse of power - as well as a blatant attempt to pervert the course of justice.
Even if the bike HAD been stolen - that's NO excuse to smash in a door and assault anyone. No wonder local police are so despised. Here's a link to a statement made by a witness regarding a similar incident. The original is signed, I've removed the identifying details to protect the privacy of the witness.
Pope and Dallinger took delight in going on about the fact that Dallinger was from Dannevirke, and the corrupt cover up of an assault on me in about 2008 in Dannevirke which I believe Dallinger was involved in, then I had to listen to a tirade from Pope about how I had allegedly ruined the lives of everyone in Carterton, so I asked him to name just one of these people, and was amazed when he came out with the name Julie Hallam, the Deputy Electoral Officer who falsely claimed I had failed to submit an expenses return after the local body elections is 2007, described in more detail at this link to 'Election by Deception, How McPhee rigged the election', the architect of her own destiny as far as the article goes, which is what Pope was referring to.
Police took no further interest in the bicycle, because it wasn't stolen, as they knew in the first place, but charged me with swearing at them, then the police prosecutor conspired with the Court to convict me of it in my absence - I hadn't even entered a plea or had proper disclosure of information.
Police continue to ignore all my complaints, telling me to come into the station "for a chat about your complaints" - what a joke!!! Evidence shows that I've been into the local police stations numerous times and been laughed at, assaulted, abused, and told to "Piss off" by corrupt local officers on every single occasion I've tried to make a complaint! .
Have a look - and a listen - to how corrupt Constables Harvey Pope and Paul Dallinger lept into action when Tim Reynolds rang up (- emergency services apparently -) and made a deliberately false accusation against me for allegedly "taking" a bicycle - it wasn't his bicycle at all and he needs to be charged with making a false complaint to police - the point is that there are two different sets of rules here - the evidence of Dallinger and Popes corrupt sadism will be added to this post very soon, including full details of how they smashed in the bedroom door to "arrest" me as a result of the phone call in the clip below, and used the phone call as an excuse to detain me at the Masterton police station all afternoon and assault and abuse me. Here's the recording of Reynolds's pathetic complaint. He is a bully and a thief. - The woman pictured in the clip below is Kirsten Grenfell of Barnardos - a trouble making, bludger, who contacted Reynolds to complain that she's got a "smack in the gob" from another woman for having it off with her partner - Grenfell richly deserved it - she is a manipulative, spiteful trouble maker who regularly sleeps with other women's partners! Grenfell urged Reynolds to evict me so that she could come round and have it off with him when her partner was working without me to witness her nauseating, adulterous behaviour.
Here are the police documents which Pope and Dallinger wasted their time writing up to try and create an excuse for their sadistic and corrupt vendetta - on the basis of this utterly pathetic phone call from a person who REPEATEDLY stated that they did NOT want to make a formal complaint!:
| CONSTABLE Harvey Pope demonstrates why he's never been promoted! |
![]() |
| CONSTABLE Pope's orchestrated litany of LIES |
![]() |
| Corrupt EX CONSTABLE Dallinger's "Jobsheet" |
| "Victims" Constables Dallinger and Pope - two grown men - two sadistic liars! |
Now, here is the second page of the records of the police communications centre regarding this incident, which shows evidence of the three calls the police call taker apparently made to Reynolds to try and talk him into making a formal complaint - Reynolds repeatedly said he didn't want to or intend to do so! Dallinger and Pope knew perfectly well that no crime had been committed! THIS is what sadistic, vindictive local officers are doing while they're deliberately covering up for child abusers and paedophiles and making sure that our region regularly has TWICE the national rate of suicide - in a country with some of the highest rates in the world - REGULARLY!
Here's what Reynolds and his mates Wayne Friend, etc, have done to my television and the keyboard I used to teach children music with - Reynolds has illegally disposed of much of my other property as well, including two guitars, and police refuse to even acknowledge any of my complaints. I've been into the Carterton, Greytown and Masterton police stations REGULARLY to report this and other vandalism and theft of my property - not to mention the assaults from Reynolds and his mates! I get told to piss off every single time!
Labels:
better work stories,
corruption,
Harvey Pope,
Kirsten Grenfell,
Paul Dallinger,
police information sharing,
Tim Reynolds,
Wayne Friend
Tuesday, July 13, 2010
Access to Court records - the Feltex cover up - guest post:
In November 2011 the Center for Legal and Court Technology at William and Mary University, Williamsburg, Virginia, in association with the National Center for State Courts and the Administrative Office of United States Courts held the 8th Conference on Privacy and Public Access to Court Records.
I was honoured to be invited to present a paper on the New Zealand experience in this area. The paper was well received and there was considerable interest in the way in which the issue was dealt with in the absence of the context of the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States and the ability of the press to report on court proceedings. By the same token, a number of Federal Courts and the US Supreme Court in particular do not allow cameras in Court whereas in New Zealand there is a specific media policy that allows this as long as there is compliance with media guidelines.
My paper, a copy of which is at the end of this post, sketched the approach in New Zealand to access to Court records. Despite an examination of the issue by the Law Commission in 2006 in its report entitled Access to Court Records, little legislative action has taken place apart from the introduction of the The Criminal Proceedings (Access to Court Documents) Rules 2009 which remedy some of the perceived access problems as far as criminal court records are concerned. However, the current rules relating to other court records are drawn from a variety of different sources, are not always consistent, clear nor easy to locate nor are they comprehensive.
There is a significant gap in the 2009 Rules. They do not cover District Court summary proceedings. This has caused some concern, because it could well be that a different process could apply to different criminal proceedings depending upon whether they have been laid summarily or indictably or, of course, where the accused has elected trial. The issue is of special interest (and no doubt concern) to the news media who routinely seek permission to access court files to obtain background and material for their reportage of court cases.
The difficulty, however, has been addressed in a case decided late last year. (Ministry of Economic Development v Feeney [2012] DCR 257)
The application arose after the summary trial and acquittal of a number of directors of Feltex Ltd. The Ministry of Economic Development sought access to the Court file to obtain copies of a transcript of evidence and written statements that had been produced during the hearing for the purposes of civil proceedings in the High Court. The application was opposed.
The grounds of the opposition were that the proceedings were not “criminal proceedings” as defined in the Criminal Proceedings (Access to Court Records) Rules, and that the notes of evidence in the District Court were in the possession of the defendants and were accessible by discovery.
As to the first ground of opposition, Chief Judge Jan-Marie Doogue held that the Criminal Proceedings (Access to Court Records) Rules did not apply because the proceedings were summary proceedings.
The relevant part of the Rules defines a “criminal proceeding” as
”a proceeding brought against a defendant—
(i) that has been commenced by information in form 2 of Schedule 2 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957; or
(ii) in which the defendant has, under section 66 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957, elected to be tried by jury; or
(iii) in which a District Court has, under section 44 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957, declined to deal summarily with the offence”
The effect of this is to exclude all summary criminal proceedings from the operation of the 2009 Rules.There had been earlier examples of what Her Honour referred to as a “legislative blindspot” in the 1974 Criminal Proceedings (Search of Court Records) Rules and after considering the way in which the High Court had earlier approached the problem, and after considering the nature of the inherent power possessed by the District Court, held that the Court has an inherent power to effectively administer its statutory jurisdiction. Such power was sufficient to order access to Court documents in criminal cases that fall outside the operation of the Rules. Whether the exercise of that jurisdiction was proper in the circumstances should be assessed by analogy to the criteria set out in the Rules.
She then went on to consider the provisions of Rules 13 and 14 which contain the procedure and the remedies that a Registrar or Judge may grant, and, importantly, set out the provisions of Rule 16 which sets out the matters that must be taken into account in considering an application.
Rule 16 provides:
“In determining an application under rule 13, or a request for permission under rule 8 or 9, or the determination of an objection under those rules, the Judge or other judicial officers or Registrar must consider the nature of, and the reasons for, the application or request and take into account each of the following matters that is relevant to the application, request, or objection:
(a) the right of the defendant to a fair hearing:
(b) the orderly and fair administration of justice:
(c) the protection of confidentiality, privacy interests (including those of children and other vulnerable members of the community), and any privilege held by, or available to, any person:
(d) the principle of open justice, namely, encouraging fair and accurate reporting of, and comment on, trials and decisions:
(e) the freedom to seek, receive, and impart information:
(f) whether a document to which the application or request relates is subject to any restriction under rule 12:
(g) any other matter that the Judge, other judicial officer, or Registrar thinks just.”
Importantly Chief Judge Doogue observed that sub-regulation (d) is concerned with media access to the Courts, and would be of importance in considering any media application for access to Court records. Each case will, of course depend upon its own circumstances as to the weight that an individual Judge or Registrar attaches to each of the criteria in considering applications.
At the moment, Court records are paper based. As I observe in my paper, the situation may well require revisiting when Court records are digitised, for the properties of digital technologies are quite different from those of the print or paper paradigm.
But discussion of those properties and their wider implications will have to take place on another day.
A copy of this paper may be found here. Other documents by the writer are also available to read at the same sites, and recommended reading for anyone interested in jurisprudence and the law.
- Source: https://theitcountreyjustice.wordpress.com/category/access-to-court-records/
Labels:
access to Court records,
Court,
Feltex,
information sharing
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)











